We've been to all of these islands, and like you, love the peace and quiet - non-touristy places. Up until 2 years ago, VG was our favorite, now
Bequia is. We believe Bequia is a prettier island and a bit more friendly. Prices for dining out (dinner and drinks) are MUCH lower than St. John and a lower in general tha VG As well. If you like VG, you'll love Bequia ...