Thread: Zeitgeist Elimination Challenge (Week 1)

Quote: Originally Posted by Esty I have yet to vote, and i'm waiting until the last minute to decide. i waited just for you....hope you made it count. and Spiral I didn't miss those...if you read my first post you'll see i could only use al bum tracks because poll limit was 12. anyway, new poll coming now.

Quote: Originally Posted by smashkin33 COME ON (LET'S GO) Davin, when's the new poll going up, so i can vote, and then forget what i voted for 2 days later! but its cool it'll be public now, so i can see what i voted for... it is the one in italics , you idiot!

Quote: Originally Posted by waltermcphilp these polls need to public so i can ridicule people who vote wrong. = truth

I actually really love that BTO intro... I think he sounds pretty. Had he tried that during, say, Siamese Dream? That would have been terrible XD I prefer Billy's voice back in the '90s just because... it was so much more unique. But he can do different things with it now, and it's still got that whine

pomp is definitely not the worst song on this album

no you haven't. stop lying. let something real through for once

Sadly it's true pomp is the weakest song on the geist.

The results are disheartening. P&C is the most MCIS song in years. It's charming and a terrific example of Pumpkins' versatile style. And it's a fucking perfect closer.

Quote: Originally Posted by Corganist I couldn't disagree with you more. I really think the production of the song on the album elevates FG&C from "nice little song" to "something memorable." I've never been the type to prefer the synthy stuff over the simpler stuff, but I think this is one of the few cases where Billy (and/or RTB, perhaps?) hit a home run by adding on the "layers of bullshit."...

Quote: Originally Posted by Corganist I'm surprised that people are surprised about P&C leading right now. For me, its probably the only easy elimination vote to make. I can't even begin to think which song I'm gonna vote off once its gone. Not that P&C isn't a perfectly good song. It is. I just like everything else on the record a whole lot better. I'm not really surprised or anything. Actually...