Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: Wings of Desire

Started 2 months ago by Arkadin
this disc may be defective. some copies have 2 small scratches on top of the silkscreen right where the "C" curves--where the color changes. (more like one extremely small scratch) you can see light pass through the disc. mine just arrived from amazon, and unfortunately has this scratch present. please examine your discs, and see if you see this. They can cause the movie to freeze during ...
Site: Blu-ray Forum - Blu-ray Community and Forums  Blu-ray Forum - Blu-ray Community and Forums - site profile
Forum: Blu-ray Movies and Releases  Blu-ray Movies and Releases - forum profile
Total authors: 13 authors
Total thread posts: 10 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: blu-ray.com

Other posts in this thread:

Beta Man replied 2 months ago
Quote: Originally Posted by jasonrw I decided to preorder it. Thanks for the feedback! You should be receiving it soon (if you haven't already) I'm curious about your take on this film...... I had it on DVD, and I'm hoping my Blu-ray arrives tomorrow...... I think it's a fantastic film, and you should be in...

retablo replied 2 months ago
Quote: Originally Posted by Arkadin this disc may be defective. some copies have 2 small scratches on top of the silkscreen right where the "C" curves--where the color changes. (more like one extremely small scratch) you can see light pass through the disc. mine just arrived from amazon, and unfortunately has this scratch ...

neo_reloaded replied 2 months ago
I've been following this on both the AVS forum and here. On AVS, the same poster that reported the defective discs said his friend had one copy with the scratches that froze, and he took it back to Best Buy and opened a second copy and saw it had the scratches too - he did not say if his friend actually exchanged for the second copy and tried to play it, only that it had the same scratches. So ...

retablo replied 2 months ago
Quote: Originally Posted by neo_reloaded I've been following this on both the AVS forum and here. On AVS, the same poster that reported the defective discs said his friend had one copy with the scratches that froze, and he took it back to Best Buy and opened a second copy and saw it had the scratches too - he did not say if his friend...

cathexist replied 2 months ago
Quote: Originally Posted by repete66211 I sat through City of Angels. The experience was unpleasant enough to dull any motivation to see what is almost certainly a superior original. Based on what I've gathered over the years (which isn't much) I don't think I would recommend a blind buy for this one. At least ...

Arkadin replied 2 months ago
yeah the deal is that the friend bought a copy and watched it, had the problems, and returned it. while there at BB he opened the other copy they had, and it ALSO had the scratches. so that's 2 copies plus mine makes 3. plus this report in the post above so that's now 4. I am not trying to say that every disc is defective, but there does seem to be an issue. so far I have watched a little ...

neo_reloaded replied 2 months ago
Quote: Originally Posted by Arkadin yeah the deal is that the friend bought a copy and watched it, had the problems, and returned it. while there at BB he opened the other copy they had, and it ALSO had the scratches. so that's 2 copies plus mine makes 3. plus this report in the post above so that's now 4. I am not trying to say ...

Arkadin replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
well I finally finished my copy this weekend, and am very happy to report that I had no freezing issues, so baring a sudden increase in poor reports, I think we can assume that even though there clearly are some discs with these small scratches, it doesn't appear that they necessarily lead to any problems. I also emailed a follow...

jasonrw replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
got my copy from amazon yesterday. i inspected the disc and it seems to be completely flawless, can't find any scratches or anything out of the ordinary. i'll be watching it this afternoon. __________________ My movie collection: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?k...5eXdmbUE&hl ...

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
jasonrw
4
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-08 23:36:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Beta Man I like owning movies too..... but I watch more than I can afford..... Up until i got my blu ray player i owned maybe 100-150 dvd's and watched about 1 movie a month (if that). Now I've been watching 3-4 a week and it's getting very expensive!!! __________________ My movie collection: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?k...5eXdmbUE&hl=en
Beta Man
3
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-08 23:19:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by jasonrw I don't have netflix. I have such mixed feelings about it.... i like owning things but i hate clutter. i've only had a blu-ray player for maybe 4 months and I already have purchased over 80 movies. that is pretty crazy. i could have had a netflix subscription for quite a few years!!! I like owning movies too..... but I watch more than I can afford.....so Netflix is great! I have 1,200 DVDs and 125...
Arkadin
3
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-08 18:18:00)
well I finally finished my copy this weekend, and am very happy to report that I had no freezing issues, so baring a sudden increase in poor reports, I think we can assume that even though there clearly are some discs with these small scratches, it doesn't appear that they necessarily lead to any problems. I also emailed a follow-up to Criterion regarding my particular disc.
neo_reloaded
2
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-06 22:30:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Arkadin yeah the deal is that the friend bought a copy and watched it, had the problems, and returned it. while there at BB he opened the other copy they had, and it ALSO had the scratches. so that's 2 copies plus mine makes 3. plus this report in the post above so that's now 4. I am not trying to say that every disc is defective, but there does seem to be an issue. so far I have watched a little over an...
retablo
2
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire
Published (2009-11-06 19:21:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by neo_reloaded I've been following this on both the AVS forum and here. On AVS, the same poster that reported the defective discs said his friend had one copy with the scratches that froze, and he took it back to Best Buy and opened a second copy and saw it had the scratches too - he did not say if his friend actually exchanged for the second copy and tried to play it, only that it had the same scratches. So...
MarkWM
2
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-12-22 14:40:00)
Outstanding film, IMHO. Peter Faulk is a pleasent suprise too I have not bought it yet but I saw it at BestBuy yesterday for $44.00! ( eek ) Last edited by MarkWM; 12-22-2009 at 02:42 PM . Reason: can't spell
broganreynik
2
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-12-22 15:29:00)
So how would you guys say this compares to "Angel-A". I really liked that movie, but didn't really like "City of Angels". I also read somewhere that Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds are in this movie, so that helps. __________________ Helpful spelling hints: 1. definitely 2. sequel 1. Inglourious 2. Basterds My Custom Blu Covers
cathexist
1
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire
Published (2009-11-06 19:40:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by repete66211 I sat through City of Angels. The experience was unpleasant enough to dull any motivation to see what is almost certainly a superior original. Based on what I've gathered over the years (which isn't much) I don't think I would recommend a blind buy for this one. At least Meg Ryan got hit by a truck... Wings of Desire is a fantastic film, and one that I have not seen for a while. I'm...
BillyJack
1
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-08 23:23:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Beta Man I like owning movies too..... but I watch more than I can afford.....so Netflix is great! I have 1,200 DVDs and 125 or so Blu-rays.... but still manage to pick up 8 or 9 per month with Netflix (in addition to watching the ones I own repeatedly) Depriving yourself of sleep is a great way to squeeze in a lot of films into the schedule...... Nothing like coming back from a bar at 3:00 am and watching a disney...
Zen_Amako
1
user's latest post:
Wings of Desire - Page 2 -...
Published (2009-11-09 02:52:00)
I also received this title from Amazon and I noticed the tiny scratches on the disc (label side). The scratches are so small, though, that I would be surprised if they affected playback. I'm looking forward to watching this film. I love Wenders' Paris, Texas, but I haven't seen this one yet. I did just watch Downfall, in which Wings of Desire's Bruno Ganz portrayed Adolf Hitler (a very good movie, by the way).

Related threads on "Blu-ray Forum - Blu-ray Community and Forums":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "Wings of Desire" on http://www.blu-ray.com. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Wings of Desire", located on the Message Board at http://www.blu-ray.com. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity