Thread: What exactly goes on in Iadio compeitions?
Started 1 month, 1 week ago by ps73
As a new entrant into the art, I haven't quite got my head round what iaido competitions consist of...
Kata?
Some form of 'gun-slinging style' shiai where speed and technique is judged?
I can visualise Kendo, obviously - but not so much iaido...
Please help educate this rookie!
ps73
2 people, side by side performing several kata. Three judges watching from the front decide which is the best and award them a win.
As simple as that, it's usually a side by side comparison, not quite the same as for a gymnastics competition or similar where you compete singly and are judged toward a standard, but similar.
Kim.
Thanks for the reply, Kim.
So that forms the basis of the competition, who performs the kata in the most accurate way?
I'd seen videos of two people about 5m apart drawing simultaneously with a referee raising a flag for who was quickets / better...does that make sense?
thanks again..!
Quote:
Originally Posted by ps73
Thanks for the reply, Kim.
So that forms the basis of the competition, who performs the kata in the most accurate way?
I'd seen videos of two people about 5m apart drawing simultaneously with a referee raising a flag for who was quickets / better...does that make sense?
thanks again..!...
Exactly as Peter says, speed is only a part of iai, much more important is timing. You'll learn that as you continue your training. The judgment is simply on which competitor performed the best set of kata.
The difficult part is often trying to decide what defines "better" but that's the judge's problem.
Kim.
Thanks for the reply, Kim.
So that forms the basis of the competition, who performs the kata in the most accurate way?
I'd seen videos of two people about 5m apart drawing simultaneously with a referee raising a flag for who was quickets / better...does that make sense?
thanks again..!
(sorry for the repeated reply above!)
Yes, I can imagine speed in itself in not improtant, more the actual technique performed and it's accuracy.
I always imagined that going into Iaido, there would be no element of competition, such as in Kendo.
But the competitive aspect of Iaido is appealing from what you all say - because it's not about fencing, but about striving to perfect a technique....
Quote:
Originally Posted by ps73
(sorry for the repeated reply above!)
Yes, I can imagine speed in itself in not improtant, more the actual technique performed and it's accuracy.
I always imagined that going into Iaido, there would be no element of competition, such as in Kendo.
But the competitive aspect of Iaido is appealing...
Quote:
Originally Posted by ps73
I'd seen videos of two people about 5m apart drawing simultaneously with a referee raising a flag for who was quickets / better...does that make sense?
That video got an airing here - and was heavily derided.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ps73
I'd seen videos of two people about 5m apart drawing simultaneously with a referee raising a flag for who was quickets / better...does that make sense?
That video got an airing here - and was heavily derided.
Quote: Originally Posted by R Stroud You can easily simulate the feeling for the spectators if you can find two unemployed painters to throw some white latex 'satin finish' up on a barn wall and then intently focus on it to see which dries first. Of course, the only thing worse is the lower back pain you get after doing Shinpan refereeing all day. Robert, it's a shame you're not near London. I've been a spinal pain...
Quote: Originally Posted by Peter West I wouldn't dirty my hands... Swiss Francs maybe... Maltese Pounds; You have 10 in Malta - - return to UK and it becomes £20. Magic!
Let me know what your Swiss bank account number is and maybe there will be a little something for you assuming I make any money off of this thing! hmmm maybe something fine to drink and a few Cuban cigars added in as well..... not sure if I want to include any of my harem in the bargin.....again all comes down to the level of preformance and the amount that it brings in for me........ I swear we need Don king to promote this event!
Quote: Originally Posted by ps73 Robert, it's a shame you're not near London. I've been a spinal pain specialist for 13yrs and would be more than happy to help you out. We could trade- I fix your back, you refine my technique (what little I have at this stage) Thanks for the offer, but I think my issues are more along the lines of what my fighter pilot uncle used to call "a short between the headset". Hope we...
Exactly as Peter says, speed is only a part of iai, much more important is timing. You'll learn that as you continue your training. The judgment is simply on which competitor performed the best set of kata. The difficult part is often trying to decide what defines "better" but that's the judge's problem. Kim.
Quote: Originally Posted by ScottUK Are you aware that Nosferatu the Ninja is actually Bill (still learning)? NOOOOO!!!!! you cant name him.... you've outed the BKA's most powerful weapon....
Thread profile page for "What exactly goes on in Iadio compeitions?" on http://www.kendo-world.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "What exactly goes on in Iadio compeitions?", located on the Message Board at http://www.kendo-world.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity