Thread: Walther P99 AS vs. Sig P226 Elite Dark

good choice! those IWI's are awesome guns, its amazing how far those guns throw brass. A few people shoot local IDPA matches with them and they do exceptionally well. However, consistency and results depend more on shooter than gun.

Thanks for the feedback, I am actually going to wait on those for now and go with an IWI Jericho 941 9mm in Steel.

Quote: chris b, i think you need to look around a little more for a sig. There are a few places online you cant CPO's and such for the same price as your quoting the P99. I would never pay more than $625 for a used Sig. Go to SigForum.com and get on there classifieds Difficult to bring some out of state guns into Massachusetts

Quote: There is no shift in change for me, im 23 years old. I have 11 handguns and only 3 are steel or alloy, but it is just the truth. More weight=less felt recoil. I have been shooting in competition-USPSA,IPSC, and IDPA since i was 17 and am always looking for a bit of an edge or benefit from a gun. If weight, seemingly doesnt matter why do people use comp's on guns? If weight doesnt matter, how come when you add a tac-light onto a...

i honestly think those who can't decide end up owning both i started my collection with a P99AS great handgun, light , comfortable then i wanted a da/sa hammer so i choose the SIG 228 either one i'll never sell ,and they are great to shoot

For something I was going to carry, I'd pick the P99AS. As a collectible, whichever one floats your boat more -- as range guns both are good.

The P99 has a better trigger, better ergos.