Thread: WWYD? "no public breastfeeding" in church bulletin
Started 2 months ago by RiverSky
So let me tell a theoretical story. Let's say a church, and just for fun, let's say it's a church that HOSTS La Leche League meetings, well, let's just say that in their church bulletin they posted a message requesting that all nursing mothers nurse in the "crying room", and stated it's for the "comfort of all our members".
If this happened in your community, (perhaps oh, I don't ...
I would anonomously call the church and make up a story. . . . something to the effect of "I am considering visiting your church and have heard rumors that some local churches are not allowing babies to be fed in the service and since I didn't want my baby to be exposed to germs (h1n1 and such) I wanted to make sure I could feed my baby in their service." I would do this to see if it is OK to ...
Well, I posted this in "Lactivism" because I think that a church telling its members not to breastfeed during services is clear discrimination against the rights of babies, and something that hinders a strong breastfeeding relationship, especially for say a new or younger mother, who might not have a lot of breastfeeding support elsewhere.
I mean, there's no way Mary didn't breastfeed Jesus ...
Before a nurse-in or contacting LLL, I'd call the church and present them with the applicable law and let them know that not allowing BFing during services is in clear violation of the law. I would give them the chance to correct the issue themselves. If they failed to change their policy, I would go ape*** as PP so eloquently put it LOL.
FWIW, that this church even has a room they call a ...
I would go to the church office during working hours and, very nicely, talk to the secretary and bring a copy of the FL law. If the secretary were to point me to someone else, I would do the same there. I wouldn't be rude about it, just assuming they weren't informed of the law.
I'm with ramama. Planning a nurse-in should not be a first response. Save it for if/when it's really needed. I would also suggest that your hypothetical friend might get a better hypothetical response from her hypothetical pastor/church leadership than you, a hypothetical stranger would.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ramama
Before a nurse-in or contacting LLL, I'd call the church and present them with the applicable law and let them know that not allowing BFing during services is in clear violation of the law. I would give them the chance to correct the issue themselves. If they failed to change their policy, I would...
I would do as a PP mentioned, bring it first to the attention of the church and give them the opportunity to fix the issue.
As to the term "cry room", it's not the best term ever, but its a traditional term for a room where parents can bring children if they are in fact having a hard time during the service. It certainly doesn't suggest that the church is anti family.
Every Catholic church I've ever been to has a cry room, and they're pretty stinking pro-family. It's not a "you must be here with your kid" place, it's a "we want you in our church and we want you to have babies, so if this makes it easier, here's a place to hang."
I'd go to the church office with law in hand, as stated. And if that didn't work, I'd go to the Diocese.
Quote: Originally Posted by anj_rn maybe they are concerned that a woman breastfeeding would be distracting to too many of their male parishoners. Not that I think that should be your problem, but you know how hard it is to concentrate with breasts around if one of your x chromosomes broke and is now a y. I think that shows a pretty low opinion of the male sex in general.
Quote: Originally Posted by RiverSky Thanks, Angela. That letter was fantastic!!! It's such a shame that you did not get a better response. I agree with you about the shame part. We never even had reciept of the letter acknowledged except by one staff member (the music minister - I was teaching a children's choir and also frequent soloist for Cantata's and things and I think he missed me! LOL). It was a truly horrible...
Quote: Originally Posted by ramama Maybe you should ask the church to make their sermons more interesting so the parishioners don't find their eyes wandering, looking around for nursing mothers LOL.
Quote: Originally Posted by annettemarie I think that shows a pretty low opinion of the male sex in general. I did not mean to offend, nor is it my personal belief, but I have been iven that excuse many times as a reason I should not bf in public.
Quote: Originally Posted by fyrwmn i'm of the opinion that God certainly would not ask you to leave in order to feed one of His children. as long as you're being discreet , than why should it be anyone else's business? But what qualifies as "discreet"? For person A, it could be: no boob showing, clothes hide everything, but no blanket. For person B, it could be: use a blanket or nursing cover. For person C, it...
Quote: Originally Posted by 2lilsweetfoxes If you were to attend the same church as us, then you might draw the same conclusion. That your baby was the only breastfed one. My baby is just under 7 months old and is breastfed. However, I leave her in the nursery with a bottle (of EBM) during services. In fact, maybe some of those bottles are filled with breast milk. I didn't really mean anything by my comment... other than I think...
Quote: Originally Posted by mamabadger I might start by speaking with the leader from the LLL chapter that meets in the church. She might be the ideal person to approach the pastor and discuss why their policy is a problem. Plus, they might want to quit meeting at this church under the circumstances. Is there any exemption for churches under the state BF law? You might want to be informed about this in advance if you are going to mention the...
I don't think it's a matter of being thin-skinned. Stating that nursing mothers are "requested" to nurse in the "crying room" for the "comfort of all our members," does not seems to be an instance where the church is trying to do nursing mothers a favor and give them a quiet and private place to nurse. I mean, I'd rather nurse in a bathroom than a room than in a roomful of...
Quote: Originally Posted by notjustmamie After giving it some more thought, I might, theoretically, take my baby to the church one Sunday and breastfeed in the service, just to see what happened. that will be interesting... i wounder what they will theoretically do... will they tell you they theoretical dont allow BF during surves to educate you because your not a normal face in the church or just leave you alone... keep us updated!
Church Bulletin Bloopers # church # humor... Church Bulletin Bloopers # church # humor http://funmeme.com/archive/2008/08/12/church-bulletin-bloopers.aspx
about a year ago
from web
Church Bulletin Bloopers: In light of Easter last... Church Bulletin Bloopers: In light of Easter last weekend, we bring you some of the best church bulletin blo.. http://tinyurl.com/2fq34q
04:12 PM April 14, 2007
from web
Getting ready to work on Church bulletin. Tomorrow:... Getting ready to work on Church bulletin. Tomorrow: church, kids free haircuts, groceries and finish up my Westside article on Mt. Vernon.
09:57 PM August 09, 2008
from web
Thread profile page for "WWYD? "no public breastfeeding" in church bulletin" on http://www.mothering.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "WWYD? "no public breastfeeding" in church bulletin", located on the Message Board at http://www.mothering.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity