Thread: Should I play Yoshi's Island 1 first?

Ah, thank you Bill. I ordered this game, Yoshi's Story on GBA and Super Mario World on GBA

You should play this first if you intend on playing both because this will likely seem like a disappointment if you had already played the first Yoshi's Island.

It doesn't matter. They both can be enjoyed regardless of the other, much like you can with SMB3 and SMW.

Doesn't really matter. Yoshi's Island DS is a sequel in the sense that it occurs after the first, but you won't be missing out on anything story-wise. The games are unrelated to each other except for premise (baby Mario) and gameplay similarities. It's not "Yoshi's Island 1" and "Yoshi's Island 2" so much as "Yoshi's Island" and "Yoshi's...