Thread: Should Carly have told Janet about Jack being in Philly?

Okay, since I can't seem to delete the post, I might as well say it. This thread has turned really fiesty. There is absolutely no call, IMO, to get so ugly. No. You. Do. Not. Have. To. Speak. In. Single. Word. Sentences. No, you are not speaking in a foreign tongue. Just because I disagree with you, that does not mean I am an idiot. I am perfectly capable of understanding you without agreeing with you. I was hoping that this could be a...

Carly haters will always find fault with her decisions even when the reasons for them are clearly unselfish. Parker has expressed concern about his father to Carly ever since she came home. He asked Janet to go find him and she declined. The kids are worried because their father is not acting like himself. Carly is going to find him to put their minds at ease. Yes she cares about Jack, but this is clearly more about the kids than Jack.

@ funnelcake: GOOD FOR THAT BUS! Janet is SCUM and deserves to be hit head-on! Carly saw Jack ON TOP OF A BUILDING, and what APPAEARED to have been in preparation to JUMP. It WAS her business because Jack is the FATHER of her kids! Am I speaking a foreign tongue? JANET was the one that came barreling over smirking and scowling to Carly's house without an invitation. Why in the hell was she there? She could have CALLED Carly and asked...

I think Holden ought to come over and stay with Sage and Parker since Carly looks like she will be gone a while. He needs a pad and his kids could come visit him and their other cousins. He could get out from under the same roof as the Demon. It would also annoy Lily, which is a plus.

Quote: Originally Posted by Astrid I'm sorry, but I'm remembering it differently. As I recall, she said that his family needs him. He mentioned that Liberty is probably happier or better off without him there right now. She said something like how Liberty doesn't have a say in that. Then, he said he didn't want her to be put in the middle and have to choose. She said it wasn't a choice because she's on his side....

Quote: Originally Posted by Astrid Carly doesn't put her kids first, IMO. Parker is not Carly's only child. There's Sage too. Remember the little girl who was so torn up over her mother going away to rehab? I distinctly remember Sage being beside herself because she hadn't gotten to say goodbye to her mother, and didn't know when she'd be back. That sounds surprisingly like the same situation with Jack now....

The funny part to me was when she mentioned to Jack that his family needed him. She mentioned her and Lib but didn't mention his kids. Don't you think they need him too? I just say it as she doesn't really consider his kids part of her family. It wouldn't be the first time. Remember the family dinner with Ralph, that Parker was not allowed to attend?

Quote: Originally Posted by Evil Girl ITA! I figure Janet already told her she can't be bothered...usual Janet me,me,me,me,me. Also love how she is hypocrite on an EPIC level to her sister about the "Uncle Ralphie" situation... I am hating janet more and more very day and someone tell that woman to cut her bangs already. I SO agree with you. And I'd really like to slap Janet!

Quote: Originally Posted by sandcastle97 Can't you hear her screaming up from the sidewalk "JACK!!! HAVE YOU HAD ANY BEERS TODAY? I DON'T SEE BEN FRANKLIN" To the cop next to her- " omg, he's seeing Ben Franklin, how many has he had? He's been drinking alot lately you may need the swat team" - OMG...that's hilarous!

Parker is clearly upset about his Father being gone. He in all fairness went to Janet first. Janet made it clear to him she wouldn't or couldn't however you care to look at this go after Jack. So he then went to his Mother and asked her to help bring Jack back. Tell me how helping your son is being a bad Mother? If your arguement is that Janet's staying for Liberty's sake is being a good Mother then how in the next breath...