I'm having a debate with another guy at my academy. He likes to reap the knee from the bottom when his oponent is standing, to transition into a leg compression or sweep.
This is similar to Maia's anaconda guard except that the outside foot would cross inside and thus reap the knee.
Now I think this is illegal because I thought that was the move that made Galvao do a surfjitsu demo on a ...
reaping can blow up your knees. Heel hooks are illegal in the gi, and a knee reap can quickly become a hands-off heel hook, which is why Galvao got so angry. If a ref sees you trying this it's possible you'll get called on it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashton
Reaping can blow up your knees. Heel hooks are illegal in the gi, and a knee reap can quickly become a hands-off heel hook, which is why Galvao got so angry. If a ref sees you trying this it's possible you'll get called on it.
Disagree.
Reaping the knee is fine, it being ...
"Reaping the knee" means covering your oponent's leg with your own to bend his knee in. Think of it as an omoplata on the leg (or legoplata).
I personally don't think the knee reap is that dangerous. At least I never heard of people being injured by it, or felt pressure on my knee in that position.
But that's not the point of this thread, I just want to know if it's legal or not to do it...
Quote:
Originally Posted by sha
"Reaping the knee" means covering your oponent's leg with your own to bend his knee in. Think of it as an omoplata on the leg (or legoplata).
I personally don't think the knee reap is that dangerous. At least I never heard of people being injured by it, or felt pressure on my knee in that position....
I really disagree with making it illegal. Do it a lot in practice (no-gi), great way to set up a toe-hold if you catch them getting lazy trying a standing pass.
"Reaping the knee" means covering your oponent's leg with your own to bend his knee in. Think of it as an omoplata on the leg (or legoplata). I personally don't think the knee reap is that dangerous. At least I never heard of people being injured by it, or felt pressure on my knee in that position. But that's not the point of this thread, I just want to know if it's legal or not to do it when your oponent...
Quote: Originally Posted by sha "Reaping the knee" means covering your oponent's leg with your own to bend his knee in. Think of it as an omoplata on the leg (or legoplata). I personally don't think the knee reap is that dangerous. At least I never heard of people being injured by it, or felt pressure on my knee in that position. But that's not the point of this thread, I just want to know if it's legal...
Quote: Originally Posted by Ashton Reaping can blow up your knees. Heel hooks are illegal in the gi, and a knee reap can quickly become a hands-off heel hook, which is why Galvao got so angry. If a ref sees you trying this it's possible you'll get called on it. Disagree. Reaping the knee is fine, it being dangerous is a fabrication from the IBJJF to further their agenda against leg locks.
Reaping can blow up your knees. Heel hooks are illegal in the gi, and a knee reap can quickly become a hands-off heel hook, which is why Galvao got so angry. If a ref sees you trying this it's possible you'll get called on it.
I really disagree with making it illegal. Do it a lot in practice (no-gi), great way to set up a toe-hold if you catch them getting lazy trying a standing pass.
Thread profile page for "Reaping the knee with standing oponent" on http://www.sherdog.net.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Reaping the knee with standing oponent", located on the Message Board at http://www.sherdog.net.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity