Thread: Questions from our Shia Brothers

Quote: Originally Posted by sticky wicket Just a few thoughts on this thorny subject.. All the differences betweeen sunni and shia stem from the article of faith the shia believe in called "imamate". imamate is the belief that God appointed specific leaders to govern mankind after Muhammad pbuh, the first being hadhrat Ali followed by certain individuals among his decendants (there are differing beliefs on the exact number and...

Quote: Originally Posted by Wazeeri I don't understand this, If Hadhrat Ali(RA) was intelligent and sensible enough to ignore his right to the khilafat in Hadhrat Abu Bakr's favour then why are his followers not following suit. We don't have any information now which Hadhrat Ali(RA) didn't have so why are we attacking the Sahaba when Hadhrat Ali(RA) didn't? If Hadhrat Ali(RA) thought these guys were evil then surely...

Quote: Originally Posted by Rudi hater Exactly, so how do you know those allegation made by Shia's are absotlute truth? I read that Shia was production of Abdullah Sabah from Yemen but then again thats what I read how much truth in it? Well you need to scrutinise what you read, and make sure its properly sourced and referenced correctly to etablish its authenticity.

Quote: Originally Posted by Zeenix Abu Huraira was asked – “Did you relate Ahadis during the time of Hazrat Omar?” He said “Omar would have beaten me with his stick , if I had done so.” May Allah guide you. The debate may be over, but I just stumbled across this. How sad that you are accussing Hadith of attacking the character of the Prophet (peace be upon him), yet you yourself, without any level of research, are willing to pass...

Quote: Originally Posted by zam When Hazrat Owais-e-Qarani heard that Nabi-e-Akram s.a.w.w has lost his teeth in Jang-e-Uhad; he broke all of his teeth one by one.......was that a kind of matam or not......... Extremely interesting analogy. Following this logic in ALL HONESTY, Shias should NOT drink water for the rest of their lives.... wouldn't that be THE REAL MATAM ? I mean Hazrat Owais-e-Qarni broke all his teeth when he heard that...

Quote: Originally Posted by zam don't divert the attention from my question please!!!!! And you are the keeper of what gate?