Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: Overweight (high BMI) and Treating...

Started 1 month, 2 weeks ago by Kathy73
I'm 1 month post treatment with SOC. What is so wrong about people with a high BMI being encouraged to try treatment? If it doesn't work by 4 or 12 weeks they can just stop the way any other treater can stop. Why can't we be encouraged too? The reason I'm putting this out there is because I don't feel that there is a whole lot of support Support Support 500 for the ...
Site: All Ask a Doctor Forums And Medical Communities - MedHelp  All Ask a Doctor Forums And Medical Communities - MedHelp - site profile
Forum: Hepatitis C  Hepatitis C - forum profile
Total authors: 20 authors
Total thread posts: 100 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: medhelp.org

Other posts in this thread:

nygirl7 replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
Isn't this the same thread as before again? Nobody isn't hoping that you do not succed - quite the opposite in fact everyone hopes to God that you SVR but pretending that the data says it's OK to be obese and do treatment = same or better odds is just not true. The FACTS are the FACTS. Just like I knew not being clear Clear by design Clear eyes Clear eyes acr Clear...

m_strings replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
NOT supportive, NYGirl. The truth is, people with higher BMI are NOT supported here because they are not encouraged to seek tx. They are told to "take a walk around the block". Look at your response. Kathy was asking for support Support Support 500 in this thread. The FACTS ARE the facts. The fact is, high BMI is NOT going to negatively affect her. It appears people ...

Kathy73 replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
I don't remember saying anyone hopes I don't succeed. In fact the thought that people here are against my success never occurred to me. And I never said it was ok to be obese and treat meaning it is equal or higher. I did say though that I don't think people should be discouraged from treating. I don't think I implying anything. I'm making a statement that if people want to try ...

dabdees replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
Kathy, No one is trying to dash any one's hopes here. If someone starts treatment with a high BMI, so be it. It is a personal choice and to my knowledge there are no studies supporting a high BMI is a positive predictor. The message is beware, look at the data that is presented and make a choice according to your own convictions. That isn't discouraging people, it's giving ...

Kathy73 replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
I thought it was the med"help"'s objective to encourage and disseminate information. That is certainly why I came on here. To get information, advice and support. To take that information and advice, correlate it with my doctor's advice and make my own decision. After making that decision to seek support here and elsewhere. I never said BMI is a positive predicator.

m_strings replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
What?

jdwithhcv replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
I think in general the members of this forum encourage every member regarding their treatment. I have not seen any particular group singled out for specific support (or non-support) whatever their diversity. I suppose nobody comes on to specifically encourage persons with high BMI but neither does anybody come on to specifically encourage persons with (for instance) nicotine ...

m_strings replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
That would be ideal. But we are all categorized in one way or another, be it by genotype, or stage of liver failure, bmi, etc. If someone identifies themselves as being in a specific category, and people continue to bring up useless information to them based on that category, we have now moved into the realm of talking about specific "groups" of people. Referring to negative ...

jdwithhcv replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
I believe clinical studies and the resulting information are useful, even when the information flies in the face of what we wish to believe. You are entitled to your opinion, of course, but in my opinion facts are important, even unpalatable ones.

m_strings replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago
Does it occur to you that Kathy's facts may be so hard for you to digest? Why are they so unpalatable to you?

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
m_strings
26
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-14 01:48:00)
Way to go!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kathy73
15
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-11 09:56:00)
Thanks for all the great information! You're the best! Kathy
Rockerforlife
7
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-10 13:43:00)
Both times on TX i started out at 200 lbs exactly....the boceprevir i think was the ticket that got me my 12 week SVR,but it is documented being obese is does affect TX outcomembeing a wee bit over you BMI is not soo bad...as long as you dont look like the pillbirys dougboy youll be ok
Trish77
7
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-11 03:53:00)
I don't know how overweight you are but being Stage 3/4, I would not let it keep you from treating.  There are other people here treating with risk factors that are different than yours .. or the same as yours.  That does not mean you won't be successful.  It means you need to be aware of how to tailor your treatment to improve your chances.   There's no...
comeagain
7
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-11 07:13:00)
Allthough very long post it wasn´t too long at all ( this time ) very good post thx a lot for making an effort!! God bless !! ca
Marcia2202
7
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-11 07:27:00)
Great information. It's good to see that you were able to find the reason to this problem and offer an approach to tackle this negative predicator.
jdwithhcv
5
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-10 15:32:00)
"For me I have to lose weight and I know it will add years to my life. " You are so right!  Apart from quitting smoking, losing excess weight is about the best thing any of us can do for our health.   I lost about 35 lbs of muscle mass during tx, and since finishing tx I have gained about 25 lbs of jiggly fat.  This was not unexpected.  During treatment...
nygirl7
5
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-10 16:22:00)
NY Girl:  Keep up" Thanks but I think I'm already ahead for the night I just don't really see the point any longer.  There are a lot of people on here who care about people in general and have spent years trying to help them.  People who seriously want help and discussion - not to just say / do the same thing over and over expecting a different answer.  You...
copyman
5
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-10 23:03:00)
Kathy, I was so caught up in the discussion that I wasn't sure if I wished you good luck. Anyway just in case I didn't, best of luck with becoming SVR. I think you will be fine. FLGuy, funny stuff. Since we are talking about momma's... your momma is so fat that she needs her picture printed out on a wide format copier ! (blue print machine). and by the way I did pick up on the word you used "fuser". this is a very...
FlGuy
4
user's latest post:
Overweight (high BMI) and...
Published (2009-11-10 15:38:00)
Your momma is a Xerox machine. The problem with comparing anything to treatment is that treatment is not all reality.  I'm not even sure that pre and post treatment is comparable.  After treatment, I put on the weigth that I lost, and then some.  I committed that I was not going to act like the post treatment gorging (which I thought I deserved) could continue.  We...

Related threads on "All Ask a Doctor Forums And Medical Communities - MedHelp":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "Overweight (high BMI) and Treating..." on http://www.medhelp.org. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Overweight (high BMI) and Treating...", located on the Message Board at http://www.medhelp.org. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity