Thread: Original Stargate Sequels

Quote: Originally Posted by Hotep Ka Heru'ur I've read most of these books (by Bill MacCay). They revealed that there is a huge network of Gates in the galaxy, just as in the TV canon that we know. Personally, I would have loved to see the Emmerich version of how the story continued - I like to imagine Independence Day, but with pyramid ships instead of the disk-shaped ones, and gliders and Horus guards patroling the ruins of New...

Quote: Originally Posted by Hotep Ka Heru'ur Well, no, because there wouldn't be a McKay in Emmerich's canon. Again, I absolutely love SG-1 and SGA (until s4/5) but I always felt that the TV format could only ever hint at the sheer awesomeness of the whole Goa'uld idea in all its grandeur that we got a glimpse of in the first movie... I for one totally want to see that. Gee some posts are taken far too literally. Of course...

Quote: Originally Posted by Phenom Everyone liked the movie to some extent, some loved it, some bit lukewarm to it. Regardless, everyone now loves SG1 and/or SGA (if not then what the heck are you doing on Gateworld??) and some have hinted they would like to see what Dev/Emm would do if they finished off their trilogy. Holy broad strokes, Batman. I liked the original movie, I love SG-1, I think Atlantis is mediocre at best. And I'd still...

Quote: Originally Posted by Phenom Everyone liked the movie to some extent, some loved it, some bit lukewarm to it. Regardless, everyone now loves SG1 and/or SGA (if not then what the heck are you doing on Gateworld??) and some have hinted they would like to see what Dev/Emm would do if they finished off their trilogy. Would you be that curious if they did finish their trilogy and for a variety of reasons it essentially killed off SG1/SGA??...

Quote: Originally Posted by Phenom And Mckay uploading the virus to the mothership!!!! Well, no, because there wouldn't be a McKay in Emmerich's canon. Again, I absolutely love SG-1 and SGA (until s4/5) but I always felt that the TV format could only ever hint at the sheer awesomeness of the whole Goa'uld idea in all its grandeur that we got a glimpse of in the first movie... I for one totally want to see that.

Well let me first say that I think it's great we can all discuss our opinions on an issue like this. It's obvious that we all love Stargate we just see things differently but I respect everyone's point of view. Quote: That wouldn't work - the reasons for the differences between the movie and SG-1 are because certain things in the movie would not work on TV. For example, the fact that the stargate only goes to one place, and...

If they ever did make a sequal to the original movie, I'd watch it just to see what direction Devlin/Emmerich wanted it to go.

Quote: Originally Posted by Bareassedmunky It wasn't so much inconsistencies with what we saw, but with the plan for the future. The stargate was only supposed to go between the two planets, Ra was the last of his race and there was a specific plan for what was to happen in the second and third movies. Actruly your wrong. I watched the Special Edition, directors cut the other day so this whole topic is kinda fresh in my mind. Anyway,...

I think the problem with the stargate franchaise thus far is the SG1/SGA team always win. They experince minor inconviniences but really all they amount to is a bunch of red shirts dying. The strongest case for this was when carson died. they brought him back of corse with a good stoyline but still it basicly means that no matter how hard it gets for the main charachters they will always win in the end. that ways one of the big problems with...

Quote: Originally Posted by Galactic Lego I think the problem with the stargate franchaise thus far is the SG1/SGA team always win. They experince minor inconviniences but really all they amount to is a bunch of red shirts dying. The strongest case for this was when carson died. they brought him back of corse with a good stoyline but still it basicly means that no matter how hard it gets for the main charachters they will always win in the...