Thread: O/T Asked my friends why they aren't wearing a poppy.
Started 1 month, 1 week ago by Janagolightly
They just said it doesn't occur to them..
Looking around my village there are only a handful of
us wearing them.
I hope Rememberance Sunday doesnt stop, I feel honoured to
remember the people who fought and gave their lives in the many wars.
They shall not grow old, as we that are left grow old. Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn them. By the going down of the sun and...
I feel honoured to
remember the people who fought and gave their lives in the many wars.
and all for nothing, too; good for them.
neither are your ways my ways
and why is remembrance such a selective thing? the Nazis who died in WWII were just as honorable in their efforts as the British, French and their allies; was their ideology totally warped? yes; did they fight to defend it? yes; same as the other team.
neither are your ways my ways
People walking around your village wearing poppys in remembrance of the war dead,it sounds fantastically quaint--what kind of village are you talking about?
I'm not denying anyone's honour - I just want to pay my respects.
I can see you want an argument which you will obviously win because
I have no wish to argue.
Auntie Em, hate you, hate Kansas, taking the dog. Dorothy.
Quaint?
It happens throughout Britain. It's not just in a few oddball villages. I doubt there are any BBC TV presenters not wearing one soon.
We are surrounded by worn-out images, and we deserve new ones.
A village in Yorkshire.
Poppies are given out for a few pence, we put them
on our garments to show our respect. They are sold in most shops all over the country.
Auntie Em, hate you, hate Kansas, taking the dog. Dorothy.
In the U.S the term village is used exclusively for very small towns---it wouldn't strike me as quaint that people in large cities are wearing symbols to memorialise the dead--its simply a very striking, timeless sounding scene.
You have already won, by giving up Jana. I think it's cute when little kids pretend to be smart by being nihilistic and by showing how typically filled to their unformed brains are with with aberrant angst.
If it doesn't matter, and is meaningless....when Jon H. makes more fun of you honoring your heroes, just shoot him.
He says it makes no difference.
So at a knock, I emptied my ...
My intention and comments never comes across as I intended, that's why I deleted the OP. I was just saying something I remembered at school that has never left me. As we were being told this lives were being lost and broadcast most nights on the tv, I remember atrocities in Northern Ireland being on the tv regularly. I know wars are raging as we speak - I think they always will whilst ever we humans inhabit this planet. If I can give 1...
Exactly. And I don't think such a view is at all "subtle", as Matthew Scott claims. If anything, it's painting things with an extremely broad brush; because war is bad, those affected by or involved in it are not worthy of being honored or remembered or cared for. "I can tell you that I am very much uninterested in whether I am shot or not."
Eleven years after the fall of Troy, We, the old men – some of us nearly forty – Met and talked on the sunny rampart Over our wine, while the lizards scuttled In dusty grass, and the crickets chirred. Some bared their wounds; Some spoke of the thirst, dry in the throat, And the heart-beat, in the din of battle; Some spoke of intolerable sufferings, The brightness gone from their eyes And the grey already thick in their hair....
It's not been 64 years since the atrocities stopped though with the greatest of respect Jana, they're happening now, they happened yesterday and they'll happened tomorrow. The advertising campaign run for poppies this time didn't say anything about WWII. I'm not complacent about the losses, my grandfather was an instructor who trained a tank regiment, one day they went out to battle in the desert, and not a single tank...
I'm astonished that any kind of psuedo-intellectual hatred of war(wow, war is bad--what a courageous stand)could prohibit people from showing respect for the ultimate sarifice so many people have made--its sad.Most adults across the world have been touched by the horrors of war and the absolute least we can do is show some respect--so Jana ,thanks for bringing up the subject for discussion.
The pacifists are wrong. Wars won't stop because people stop seeing them as honorable. They'll just be won by agressors more often. Victims of the Holocaust didn't put up much of a fight for the most part. It didn't stop nazis from killing them. The notion that it's wrong to fight against agression is evil. Is that quote James Garner? "Lots of FAMOUS people can't read!"
Poppy wearing - do people really feel guilty re not... Poppy wearing - do people really feel guilty re not wearing one?Just put £ in the tin, remember on the 11th,and leave the poppy in the tray. 3:53 AM Nov 3rd from web
Thread profile page for "O/T Asked my friends why they aren't wearing a poppy." on http://www.imdb.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "O/T Asked my friends why they aren't wearing a poppy.", located on the Message Board at http://www.imdb.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity