Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
Loading... 

Thread: ON Hydrowhey is it worth the extra cash? (Review by SwissMuscle)


Started 4 months, 3 weeks ago by SwissMuscle
Hello, Since protein consumption is a lifestyle, we spend a lot of our hard earned cash every day on protein. We must make sure we are getting the most for our money and avoid being sucked into marketing hype. As a loyal fan of Optimum Nutrition I decided to go ahead and purchase both flavors of Platinum Hydrowhey after hearing all this hype about this new super protein. I have been ...
Site: Bodybuilding.com Forums - Bodybuilding And Fitness Board  Bodybuilding.com Forums - Bodybuilding And Fitness Board - site profile
Forum: Product Reviews - Help Out!  Product Reviews - Help Out! - forum profile
Total authors: 15 authors
Total thread posts: 26 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: bodybuilding.com

Other posts in this thread:

shadar replied 4 months, 3 weeks ago
Thanks for the review with all the number crunching you did. But really none of that is the purpose of hydrowhey. The entire point of taking a hydrolyzed whey is because it is supposed to get to your muscles faster than standard whey protein does. Thus it is not meant as a direct swap-out for regular whey, in fact regular whey would likely be better to take most times, only post workout ...

justin6683 replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Quote: Originally Posted by Chinkydelight Great review OP! now we know not to believe the hype! Good product imo i use it....

SwissMuscle replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Quote: Originally Posted by shadar Thanks for the review with all the number crunching you did. But really none of that is the purpose of hydrowhey. The entire point of taking a hydrolyzed whey is because it is supposed to get to your muscles faster than standard whey protein does. Thus it is not meant as a direct swap-out for ...

Sylis replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
nice number crunching, well i guess i'm not gonna give it a try since it doesnt rly seem to be all its hyped up to be....

Num3n replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
reps to op for doing all this work, great write up mate.

N54 replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
You did some of your math wrong OP. Gold Standard is 18% BCAA.

shadar replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Quote: Originally Posted by SwissMuscle "Shadar" My review was not about absorption speed because there is no way for me to test this. Besides the gold standard protein already has hydrowhey in it. People wanted to know if it was worth spending twice as much money and upgrade from gold standard to the Hydrowhey. The advertisement...

shadar replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Quote: Originally Posted by N54 You did some of your math wrong OP. Gold Standard is 18% BCAA. It looks like the problem in his numbers is his 24g number he used whereas it should be 30-32 depending on which flavor he picked. Probably impacts all his numbers by about 20% but still doesn't change the final ...

SwissMuscle replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Only one calculation was off, the fact that I calculated from 24g protein instead of 29.4g serving for the BCAA Gold standard calculation. My apologies and thank you N54 for your assistance! There are 18% BCAA in the Gold standard. 4% less than the Hydrowhey. So that would mean the Hydrowhey provides about 1 gram more of BCAAs than Gold Standard (using the 29 gram serving dose from Gold ...

Bliptrip replied 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Optimum Nutrition: Solid products, solid overhyping, solid overpricing.

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
shadar
7
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-12-16 11:08:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by afranczyk I think it should be mentioned that both proteins are hydrolyzed (gold standard and hydro whey.) You cannot super hydrolyze a protein, as soon as its broken down to their respective peptides, amino acids are next. I know you mention a value, but even if a peptide was 4 chains now, instead of 6, whats that going to change, like 20 seconds in digestion? Gold Standard includes "some"...
SwissMuscle
4
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-02 19:08:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Gregry Great Review. I myself will just stick to 100% Gold because it's cheap and seems to do the trick for me. You welcome. And what some of seem to forget is that Gold Standard already contains Hydrowhey in the blend!
AnhYeuMy
3
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-12-16 00:13:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by shadar In the end it really is just protein... so no dosing scheme will really be too bad. Just throw half a scoop in with 1 scoop of another protein and you'll likely be getting almost all the benefits of the hydrowhey and you'll also be getting plenty of protein from the other source as well. That assumes you usually use 1.5-2 scoops post. If you only do 1 scoop then do 1/2 and 1/2. I really don't...
Mfusick
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-03 18:12:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by SwissMuscle Hello, Since protein consumption is a lifestyle, we spend a lot of our hard earned cash every day on protein. We must make sure we are getting the most for our money and avoid being sucked into marketing hype. As a loyal fan of Optimum Nutrition I decided to go ahead and purchase both flavors of Platinum Hydrowhey after hearing all this hype about this new super protein. I have been using the gold...
HeismanWatch
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-04 22:35:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by SwissMuscle Hello, Since protein consumption is a lifestyle, we spend a lot of our hard earned cash every day on protein. We must make sure we are getting the most for our money and avoid being sucked into marketing hype. As a loyal fan of Optimum Nutrition I decided to go ahead and purchase both flavors of Platinum Hydrowhey after hearing all this hype about this new super protein. I have been using the gold...
italican07
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-12-15 21:55:00)
For anybody using Hydrowhey, how many scoops do you take of it postworkout?
justin6683
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-02 08:52:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Chinkydelight Great review OP! now we know not to believe the hype! Good product imo i use it....
Sylis
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-02 15:27:00)
nice number crunching, well i guess i'm not gonna give it a try since it doesnt rly seem to be all its hyped up to be....
afranczyk
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-12-16 00:31:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by shadar The entire point of taking a hydrolyzed whey is because it is supposed to get to your muscles faster than standard whey protein does. I think it should be mentioned that both proteins are hydrolyzed (gold standard and hydro whey.) You cannot super hydrolyze a protein, as soon as its broken down to their respective peptides, amino acids are next. I know you mention a value, but even if a peptide was 4 chains...
Num3n
1
user's latest post:
ON Hydrowhey is it worth the...
Published (2009-11-02 16:10:00)
reps to op for doing all this work, great write up mate.

Related threads on "Bodybuilding.com Forums - Bodybuilding And Fitness Board":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "ON Hydrowhey is it worth the extra cash? (Review by SwissMuscle)" on http://www.bodybuilding.com. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "ON Hydrowhey is it worth the extra cash? (Review by SwissMuscle)", located on the Message Board at http://www.bodybuilding.com. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity