Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: Mixing different ammo in a magazine.

Started 2 months ago by 357MagFan
Can this potentially cause a problem? I have 2 13 round magazines for a Glock 21. 20 200 grain corbon JHPs 12 Speer JHPs "I lost the box, they are old, I don't remember what weight the bullet is" I don't have enough Corbons to fill up both magazines and am missing a round for the Speer magazine. I don't want to have to buy a whole new box of Corbons and pay 30 bucks just for ...
Site: The Firing Line  The Firing Line - site profile
Forum: Handguns: General Handgun Forum  Handguns: General Handgun Forum - forum profile
Total authors: 11 authors
Total thread posts: 12 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: thefiringline.com

Other posts in this thread:

RickB replied 2 months ago
If the gun functions with both rounds, mixing them in the same mag won't cause any problems.

JohnKSa replied 2 months ago
I have seen it stated more than once in print, in respectable publications, by respected authors that mixing different types of ammunition (different loadings, different bullet styles, etc.) can cause malfunctions in otherwise reliable pistols. I do not understand why that would be true and I have never experienced it. I do not claim to have done extensive testing but I have, on occasion, ...

inSight-NEO replied 2 months ago
I see no compelling reason at all to mix ammo (within a magazine). Now, loading one mag up with JHP and another with FMJ (or whatever)....that I have no issue with. But, again, mixing ammo together within the same mag? Unnecessary and IMHO, not recommended. Besides, do both mags need to be loaded to max capacity? No. For various reasons, I keep my double stack mags (13 round capacity) ...

357MagFan replied 2 months ago
Thank you JohnKsa

Elvishead replied 2 months ago
45s are to weak, you should get a 10mm.

DasFriek replied 2 months ago
10mm is to weak,get a 50 BMG. On topic tho, I kinda mix my ammo,that is my first round in every gun is a FMJ to save on ammo and setback as i seem to repeatedly load and unload my weapons going to the range. But after that first round that in the chamber the mags always have the same ammo. My 1911 can ruin any round in 2 chamberings,CorBon was great enough to replace a box of .45 for...

kraigwy replied 2 months ago
If they both function, what's the problem??? Of course you can mix them. Quote: I don't have enough Corbons to fill up both magazines and don't want to have to buy a whole new box of Corbons and pay 30 bucks just for 1 bullet, Yeah you deffentantly dont want extra ammo laying around the house.

Hafoc replied 2 months ago
I don't know why mixing different ammo in the same mag should cause any problems. But I did have one automatic pistol that would jam when I did this. I can't remember the details; it was a long time ago. I seem to remember it was a .40 S&W, I was trying to use hardball, Blazer aluminum-cased hollowpoints, and brass-cased hollowpoints, and it would jam with any combination of those three, but...

KyJim replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
I read the other thread JohnKSa referred to. I can accept the fact that mixing ammo will cause more feeding issues but have trouble understanding why this happens. The only reason I can think of is that in rapid firing, the shooter gets into a rhythm and, that by mixing ammo type, the rhythm is somehow mismatched and causes problems similar to limp wristing. Just a theory, though, without any...

teifmen1948 replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
When I'm at the range plinking away, I dont worry about it. I've never experinced any failures from mixing ammo. For carry, I'd stick to one type of ammo.

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
357MagFan
2
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-07 15:09:00)
Thank you JohnKsa
Elvishead
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 04:15:00)
45s are to weak, you should get a 10mm.
JohnKSa
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-07 15:03:00)
I have seen it stated more than once in print, in respectable publications, by respected authors that mixing different types of ammunition (different loadings, different bullet styles, etc.) can cause malfunctions in otherwise reliable pistols. I do not understand why that would be true and I have never experienced it. I do not claim to have done extensive testing but I have, on occasion, fired a magazine full of mixed loads without issue....
RickB
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-07 13:25:00)
If the gun functions with both rounds, mixing them in the same mag won't cause any problems.
inSight-NEO
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-07 15:05:00)
I see no compelling reason at all to mix ammo (within a magazine). Now, loading one mag up with JHP and another with FMJ (or whatever)....that I have no issue with. But, again, mixing ammo together within the same mag? Unnecessary and IMHO, not recommended. Besides, do both mags need to be loaded to max capacity? No. For various reasons, I keep my double stack mags (13 round capacity) downloaded to 10 rounds each. Do I feel less prepared?...
DasFriek
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 10:07:00)
10mm is to weak,get a 50 BMG. On topic tho, I kinda mix my ammo,that is my first round in every gun is a FMJ to save on ammo and setback as i seem to repeatedly load and unload my weapons going to the range. But after that first round that in the chamber the mags always have the same ammo. My 1911 can ruin any round in 2 chamberings,CorBon was great enough to replace a box of .45 for me that 50% of them had setback after just 3 months of...
kraigwy
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 10:21:00)
If they both function, what's the problem??? Of course you can mix them. Quote: I don't have enough Corbons to fill up both magazines and don't want to have to buy a whole new box of Corbons and pay 30 bucks just for 1 bullet, Yeah you deffentantly dont want extra ammo laying around the house.
Hafoc
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 10:38:00)
I don't know why mixing different ammo in the same mag should cause any problems. But I did have one automatic pistol that would jam when I did this. I can't remember the details; it was a long time ago. I seem to remember it was a .40 S&W, I was trying to use hardball, Blazer aluminum-cased hollowpoints, and brass-cased hollowpoints, and it would jam with any combination of those three, but function perfectly with any one of...
Courageous Lion
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 21:46:00)
The problem I would see with mixing is that they could have different recoils and make it a lot more difficult for you to stay on target if you had to use them for self defense. Find a round you can be happy with after some practice and keep 10 in each magazine or 13 if you don't worry about the spring setting.
teifmen1948
1
user's latest post:
Mixing different ammo in a...
Published (2009-11-08 21:39:00)
When I'm at the range plinking away, I dont worry about it. I've never experinced any failures from mixing ammo. For carry, I'd stick to one type of ammo.

Related threads on "The Firing Line":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "Mixing different ammo in a magazine." on http://www.thefiringline.com. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Mixing different ammo in a magazine.", located on the Message Board at http://www.thefiringline.com. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity