Thread: Kimura as dangerous as the heelhook! - Page 6 - Sherdog Mixed Martial Arts
Forums
Started 1 month, 1 week ago by Wolfwood
I broke my radial bone from a bicep slicer in a match
that is my only major bjj injury
I don't want that outlawed
just saying
__________________
Jiu jitsu competition brings us down the path of self discovery
By revealing hidden weaknesses within our techniques
We can defeat our only true enemy which is ourself...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfwood
I broke my radial bone from a bicep slicer in a match
that is my only major bjj injury
I don't want that outlawed
just saying
No one's talking about outlawing anything.
__________________
Nova Uniao BJJ...
I don't ever do heel-hooks, although they're lethal because of the danger. In terms of kimuras, though, I think the difference is that with the heel hook, you can have your knee damaged before you feel pain. That in combination with the degree of the injury are what make heelhooks so dangerous. I don't know of anyone that can say that (no pain before injury) about a kimura. ...
The Kimura is actually a problem with people who don't know how to restrain themselves when they get the submission happening. Once the hand is effectively behind the back of the opponent it has to be applied sensitively (still can be fast) just like the omoplata. The thing is once you get to this point the kimura is still super hard to get out of but doesn't feel as secure as the...
I think the "danger" of the kimura is caused by the veritable barrage of kimuras that occur in grappling. I had a thread a while back about what people thought the most versatile submissions were, and I think kimura took it. You can hit them from so many places it makes your head spin. So obviously if kimuras outnumber the next most common submission by a factor of X to 1, then ...
Great find, Drew. My opinion on the matter relates to my personal experience of thinking "down the line", and I think this can only come into play by asking people the following:
Have you had a shoulder injury? Is it permanent? Were there any major effects on your daily lifestyle as a result of the injury?
From there, substitute "shoulder" with "knee". The interpretation ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Drew Foster
If you don't think Kimuras cause more injuries than straight armbars I don't know what to say...... When your arm goes straight, you know to tap and the opponent knows that the arm is straight. Everyone's arms bend at different angles nd to different degrees. I know of at least 5 ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfwood
I broke my radial bone from a bicep slicer in a match
that is my only major bjj injury
I don't want that outlawed
just saying
QFT! If anything is a silent killer in training the bicep slicer is it. Personally I think this is silly. The main reason people ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikey Triangles
QFT! If anything is a silent killer in training the bicep slicer is it. Personally I think this is silly. The main reason people get hurt from submissions is because they're not training them enough/properly so by banning a technique from white belts you're only making them ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Drew Foster
Mikey, NO ONE has talked about banning anything man.
ummm, so what's this doing in your first post then:
Quote:
"White belts are not allowed to use the Kimura Armlock in my Academy!"
I can understand...
Quote: Originally Posted by megatonjits if you think kimura's are bad check out this reverse kimura that nearly tore my shoulder off at 2:35. I didn't realize how bad it was tell my last match. YouTube - Oregon Open 2009 - Blue Belt from ImpactJJ - Rodney Buswell That was an Americana/Keylock/Paintbrush/Udegarami, but if you want to call it a reverse Kimura that's fine. And that was very wicked. You get hurt? __________________...
Quote: Originally Posted by Drew Foster Mikey, since you said I put words in dave's mouth: "Competition is a different story. You should have a separate competition class in which you can introduce the submission." okay, so then he does allow it I guess. Really it's not that big a deal either way. I was just trying to offer my opinion on the subject.
Quote: Originally Posted by Crazy Legs What the hell are you talking about? There aren't any credible statistics posted in this thread. Rener didn't say more dangerous, he said more injuries occur as a result of toe holds (which we can only assume is at his academy). There is a difference. Risk refers to probability of something bad happening NOT the number of instances or severity of damage. An RNC can end your life so by your hand...
Quote: Originally Posted by Drew Foster WHY DON'T YOU GUYS TELL THIS POOR FELLA THAT HE WAS TOO STUBBORN TO TAP: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtMonVbdYxw That was pretty nasty and that happens. Guy on top just went batshit insane with how fast he cranked it. He had the triangle the guy wasn't going anywhere he didn't have to apply it that fast. I use that combo a lot and everytime I land it there is no reason at all to crank...
Quote: Originally Posted by Drew Foster Mikey, you're creating a topic within a topic. Stick to the issue. This isn't about Dave Camarillo. It's about the danger of a Kimura vs. a Heelhook. I thought this thread was still about Ken Shamrock? __________________ "I'm mainly a student of Krav Maga, mixed with a little bit of Systema and Combat Tai Chi... the 3 of those arts combined, I for the most part have a ton of...
if there ever was a heel hook equivalent arm submission, i would have to say the real 'silent killer' is the wrist lock. it's such a delicate joint and so easy to crank on it, with a short threshold from nothing to excruciating pain... plus it puts your wrist out of comission for a few weeks to a month, or it can make it never quite 100 percent again.
Quote: Originally Posted by Tim Ager Kimuras and heelhooks are only dangerous to those who don't know how to tap or are allowed to roll from day 1. Every white belt should be taught submissions and when they know what the submission feels like then they should be fine. Some people just refuse to tap for whatever reason. There's two sides to this coin. Newbs who slap and crank a heel hook will cause damage before their opponents have...
Quote: Originally Posted by Drew Foster Jinxes/Superstition is all bullshit. Don't believe the hype. Sorry if you are injured though. Yah they are lol. Fortunately I'm have those weird Gumby shoulders, so Kimura's REALLY got to be yanked on me to feel anything. There's only one angle where I feel it right away, and that's if someone has it on me where they are over my head in a side-back mount sort of position....
Quote: Originally Posted by Drew Foster WHY DON'T YOU GUYS TELL THIS POOR FELLA THAT HE WAS TOO STUBBORN TO TAP: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtMonVbdYxw Terrible video. I always been a lot more careful with EVERY submission, performed by me or on me, after I saw that one. Plus, the guy slapping it is a black belt vs a beginner, right?
Quote: Originally Posted by DarceBrabo ^^^^^ Another case of someone arguing their opinion vs. statistics. All of the things that you just regurgitated from Rener's mouth has nothing to do with this topic as far as Danger is concerned, but i'll indulge you by saying your totally off with your assessment. Not to mention the fact that Heel Hooks are actually more dangerous than Toe Holds (in spite of what Rener Gracie says). Im...
Related threads on "Sherdog Mixed Martial Arts Forums":
Thread profile page for "Kimura as dangerous as the heelhook! - Page 6 - Sherdog Mixed Martial Arts
Forums" on http://www.sherdog.net.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Kimura as dangerous as the heelhook! - Page 6 - Sherdog Mixed Martial Arts
Forums", located on the Message Board at http://www.sherdog.net.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity