Thread: I don't understand why people say the 4th film was the best

because I always thought from the first 5 books, Goblet was always the best it was in the books the best part was the end with the fake moody R.I.P the true Skins RIP C Creevey Benett battle idiot for remakes

I actually think the third one is even worse. Have You Ever Noticed How Sexy Mirrors Are?

I don't think the third film was EXCELLENT, but I think it struck the best balance between being true to the story and being a well made film. The first two were VERY true to the books, but as films they never felt like more than adaptations of better books. OOTP was quite good as a film but it ignored SO MUCH of the subject matter that it made for an inadequate adaptation. And GOF not only ignored most of the story, it was also a poorly...

While I think any is better than 1 and 2, simply because those are too dull to rewatch, Goblet of Fire is easily the worst adaptation, it cut out so much , no development to the outside new characters. I get mad because the 4th got better reviews than Order of the Phoenix, even though the 5th, and also HBP, are a LOT better than the 4th, as is the 3rd. It is a three-way tie between my fav HP film, the 3rd, 5th, or 6th. The first two are too...

I read somewhere that Mike Newell wanted GOF to be a Bollywood extravaganza. I think he's got it. I remember loving GOF when I first saw it, and then after several viewings I realized it wasn't a great movie. I think that was the intention, it was almost like they put a spell on us. The film was well marketed, that's all I can say, and the Triwizard Scenes were kept intact, and those three action scenes alone that lead up to...

"I don't understand why people say the 4th film was the best." I suppose they say it because they think it and believe it. I may disagree with them, but I understand. They're just stating an opinion. Not everyone thinks alike. It's not uncommon to encounter people that have a different opinion from your own, not just about Harry Potter films, but everything! Is this really a new concept to you?

Completely agreed. back when it came out I said that I thought it was a joke and where was the real film... I still dislike that film but not as much as I dislike CoS. "Some of their number had been lost and those who had survived were weary"

And you are.. how old??? To proclaim how inmature the movies are?? 12? 16? or, ok, maybe 20? However , not even the point: After Order of the Phoenix and Half Blood Prince ... Goble of Fire is the best film ever. Do you recognize my voice...?

Philosopher 9/10 Great all-round kids film Chamber 7/10 Mostly a rehash of the original Azkaban 8/10 By far the best direction, but the worst pacing in terms of the series. I felt cauron cut too much and the last act suffered for it Goblet 9/10 Great action, good character development, incredible ending, i love the whole feel of this movie Phoenix - 8.5/10 Strong themes and developments, but I think Yates is the weakest director of the series...

Seriously, I've seen all of them recently and I can say without any doubt that the fourth film is the worst of all harry potter films. The editing was pointless, the story was very poorly told and the scenes were very bad written, I really felt that special efects were over the writing and the story. Seeing "Order of the Phoenix" later was a completely different experience, and a very good one indeed. Goblet of Fire...