I have been unable to find any information regarding the finish process HL uses on their slide. I only found a reference to it being their "severe elements" finish.
Does anyone have any knowledge of the process they use and the real world durability of the process? Does it hold up well? Does the color come off easy?
What is this HK you speak of?
Good question for which I do not know the answer, but would like to...what's up HK guys?
FWIW with my limited experience, it seems pretty tough, but I haven't tried C4 or Piranha's yet.
In short HK's finish sucks (tho, not as bad as Sigs)
They are notorious for having finish wear on the Sharp edges, and controls.
It's not bad on the Flats, but for $800 dollar guns I expect more.
This is what I noticed on my USP45.
On a side note I believe they had issues with .357sig in the USP platform, but I could be wrong.
04-07-2008, 08:59 PM
Quote:
HK lovers can have them
Today, 01:24 PM
Quote:
HK handguns: Slide finish?
I sense a little voice in your head telling you "You want an HK".
Try holding a P30 or the HK45/HK45C.
The P30 is the most comfortable pistol I've ever held.
It feels like it was injection ...
I own or have owned several and ignorant me has never really committed to memory the finish process. I am certain that people on HKPro.com will know. Those guys know everything there is to know about the HK. I have never had a problem with the finish on them. USP.45, USP.45c, USP.40, USPc SS .45, USP.45 Tactical, P30, P2000, and HK45c. I know, ridiculous. Still, so many guns, so little money.
Like kristop said, they do tend to show wear pretty bad on the corners and edges. But all the wear on mine is from carrying ie. holstering/unholstering, haven't noticed anymore wear than other carry guns. I haven't had any problems with rust at all, I think it just tends to add a little character.
The HK finish is called HE for Harsh Environment and is a nitro-carburized process. It is very hard and durable. The longest I've carried an HK is only two years but so far there is little to no holster wear evident. The only downside to this process is that it colors a bit differently depending on the hardness of the steel.
Quote:
I am certain that people on HKPro.com will know.
Thanks, I will try a post over there. Too bad their forum seems to lack a search feature.
Quote:
The HK finish is called HE for Harsh Environment
I guess I was close when I said "severe elements" finish.
Quote: You gotta wonder why gun manufacturers don't just use a natural oxidation finish, ala Statue of Liberty or Naval Jelly. It's gonna oxidize anyway, why not just do a preemptive strike of sorts? Someone told me the other day you can bead blast off the black finish on a Glock slide and leave the grey protective finish. They said it looks pretty good.
Quote: Yep! Once he fondles a P30 it will be over. Yup, I hadn't been back from deployment 2 hours before I was at the local gun shop. I didn't even know the P30 was out yet but there one was under the glass, I picked it up and about a minute later I was filling out the 4473.
i recently read a post that asked the same question in the hk forums and the answer from the experts are as follows. the finnish is not a finnish in that it is chemically bonded to the metal and even though it may seem that the finninsh is wearing off it is still protected due to the bonding process (it is in the steel rather than on it) and with a lifetime warranty thats good enough for me
That harsh environment treatment is supposed to be a process that goes beyond finish deep, and can supposedly weather extreme environments, including salt water quite well, maybe even better than most, but... it WILL mark/scratch fairly easily so keep it away from belt buckles and such
You gotta wonder why gun manufacturers don't just use a natural oxidation finish, ala Statue of Liberty or Naval Jelly. It's gonna oxidize anyway, why not just do a preemptive strike of sorts?
In short HK's finish sucks (tho, not as bad as Sigs) They are notorious for having finish wear on the Sharp edges, and controls. It's not bad on the Flats, but for $800 dollar guns I expect more. This is what I noticed on my USP45. On a side note I believe they had issues with .357sig in the USP platform, but I could be wrong.
04-07-2008, 08:59 PM Quote: HK lovers can have them Today, 01:24 PM Quote: HK handguns: Slide finish? I sense a little voice in your head telling you "You want an HK". Try holding a P30 or the HK45/HK45C. The P30 is the most comfortable pistol I've ever held. It feels like it was injection molded right into your hand. Be sure to post a range report when you get one.
Thread profile page for "HK handguns: Slide finish?" on http://www.thefiringline.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "HK handguns: Slide finish?", located on the Message Board at http://www.thefiringline.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity