Thread: Gfactor: Please explain why you didn't issue a warning
Started 1 month, 3 weeks ago by tacoloco
Reference: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/...0&postcount =71
Someone makes a threat of violence in a PM and all you can do is advise them not to do it again?
From my chair all that business about "we wouldn't have heard about it" is just hand waving for not doing what was obviously called for.
Really Not All That Bright replied 1 month, 3 weeks ago
Note that the PM was directed at me, I didn't report it, and I specifically asked the moderators not to make a board issue out of it when they contacted me because other people reported it.
I posted it in the public thread because it was a douchey thing to say, just as I might have quoted a regular post in which somebody said something really stupid that nobody else noticed. If I'd had a ...
Really Not All That Bright replied 1 month, 3 weeks ago
Same reason it's up to me to decide whether or not to press charges if you poke me in the eye. Anyway, I didn't demand that they let it go - I asked if they would do so if I had any say in the matter. For what it's worth, I personally insulted him first (though not via PM).
Incidentally, if you read the PM FAQ, you'll see it doesn't address what rules may or may not be in place as far as PM ...
Quote:
Same reason it's up to me to decide whether or not to press charges if you poke me in the eye.
If you lose your eye (or become seriously injured in some other fashion) when I poke it, it stops being up to you on what happens to me, is it not? But either way, you have a decent point. I still think it's not right at all for bri not to even ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Really Not All That Bright
Note that the PM was directed at me, I didn't report it, and I specifically asked the moderators not to make a board issue out of it when they contacted me because other people reported it.
I understand what you're saying, but I don't really think it's your ...
I thought that a threat of violence was cause for an instant Ban or Suspension regardless of where it was posted.
What if he would have threatened to file a law suit against the SDMB in a PM?
For clarity, I'm not asking for the mods to change the decision, as I have no particular beef with Bri. I'm just looking for some sort of rational explanation.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hajario
I thought that a threat of violence was cause for an instant Ban or Suspension regardless of where it was posted.
Here is the Pit rule:
Quote:
Do not threaten harm or wish death on another poster
Do not threaten another poster with physical...
Quote: Originally Posted by NineToTheSky The stumbling block for many changes to the Dope has always been that Jerry has other priorities, due to the parlous finances of CL. Does anyone have any updates on the financial situation? Updates on the financial situation have been cut due to the financial situation.
Quote: Originally Posted by NineToTheSky The stumbling block for many changes to the Dope has always been that Jerry has other priorities, due to the parlous finances of CL. Does anyone have any updates on the financial situation? Due to financial considerations, Jerry has been replaced with "Cardboard Cutout Jerry".
Perhaps a different sort of hack? A hack that prevents people from editing a message they are attempting to forward? If such a thing exists or is even possible.
Quote: Originally Posted by Gfactor ...3. Please review my previous posts for my explanation of my decision. I'm not going to reconsider it a second time. Sorry, I didn't mean to suggest you need a re-do in this particular case. I was asking about frequency of occurence and other stuff to try getting a handle on whether some kind of rule or procedural change might be beneficial for the next death threat delivered through PM.
Quote: Originally Posted by Lynn Bodoni We can't verify PMs that are sent between posters. I'm sure that there's a hack, but we don't have it functioning on this message board. Our system admin, from what I understand, does other IT work at the Reader, and isn't inclined to dig around in the SDMB for PMs. So, just how do you suggest that the moderation staff deal with PMs that are posted, if we can't verify just...
Quote: Originally Posted by Gfactor Actually, no. Please forward the PM to a moderator and state your complaint. We will do something about it. Moreover, the rules do not currently prohibit posting PM content, so you are free to do that, as long as you don't violate another rule in the process. Thanks for the answer G-man! That makes a lot more sense than the earlier "Just ignore it and hope it goes away" response.
Yeah, I really don't care if people modify their behaviors or not. And the guy didn't say cunt in the pit. He said it in a private message. There's nothing about being called a cunt that bothers me in any way, so if you want to drop the c-bomb on me in the pit (which isn't allowed on this board, but I have no personal beef with), in PM, at the bar, or wherever, I just dismiss you as an asshole, and don't really think...
British Police Issue Warning Over Cannabis Laced with... British Police Issue Warning Over Cannabis Laced with Cocaine: West Yorkshire Police: Police Issue War.. http://tinyurl.com/5q6spp 1:15 PM Nov 14th, 2008 from twitterfeed
Thread profile page for "Gfactor: Please explain why you didn't issue a warning" on http://www.straightdope.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Gfactor: Please explain why you didn't issue a warning", located on the Message Board at http://www.straightdope.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity