Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: FTF Question - what am I missing?

Started 1 month, 1 week ago by w00dc4ip
Reloading newbie here with what I'm hoping is a newb question. I'm trying to load 9mm 124 grain JHP rounds but having trouble and not sure what the problem is. Details are below but the problem is the round is failing to completely chamber and then keeping the slide from closing. This happens with all of my 9mm firearms (no glocks). My Beretta gave a little more information as the slide ...
Site: THR  THR - site profile
Forum: Handloading and Reloading  Handloading and Reloading - forum profile
Total authors: 13 authors
Total thread posts: 32 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: thehighroad.org

Other posts in this thread:

Jim Watson replied 1 month, 1 week ago
If they won't go in the chamber, they won't shoot. It looks like you need some taper crimp on the case, at least eliminate the flare or close it down SLIGHTLY. If you stuck a bullet in the rifling, the OAL is too long. Seat the bullets and crimp to where the round will chamber FREELY and extract in one piece. Yes, shorter OAL will reduce working volume in the case and increase ...

Deavis replied 1 month, 1 week ago
First of all, get a case gage. Any of your barrels will do in the short term but a case gage is a simple way fo diagnosing issues like this. Drop the round in there and you will be able to see where it is hanging up in the gage and quickly diagnose this. 1.142" is not too long for 9mm, the maximum length is 1.169" but the longest I personally use, even with 124s is 1.130". You can find ample...

RidgwayCO replied 1 month, 1 week ago
You've already got the only case gauge that matters... your barrel. Remove it from your Beretta, drop a factory round in, and note the position of the case in the barrel. Now try one of your reloads and note the position. Is it the same? If yes then you should be good to go. If not, then check your crimp and/or reduce the COL to get the same position as the factory round. My experience with the ...

F_L replied 1 month, 1 week ago
Use a case gauge or a barrel and see what the max length you can load to. I load 9mm for a Sig P6. Max length for this pistol is 1.065 or it will stick in the lands. All ready said but start at the lowest charge and work your way up. For 124 gr LRN I started at 3.4 gr bullseye and worked up to 3.8. Works good in the P6. Fred

chris in va replied 1 month, 1 week ago
I had the same problem loading 124gr TC bullets. Initial OAL was 1.11 as suggested in my Lyman manual, but they wouldn't chamber in my CZ or HiPoint carbine. I ended up with 1.04oal with that particular bullet. And I agree about a taper crimp, really helps in my case.

w00dc4ip replied 1 month, 1 week ago
Will order a case gauge later this week. Beretta is a 92fs INOX. Beretta allowed round to chamber right around 1.140" I've gotten rounds to chamber in all my 9mm firearms consistently by reducing OAL of the rounds to 1.075". The pickiest barrels were from the P6 and XD, which both needed the rounds to reduce under 1.080", but consistently allowed rounds to chamber at 1.075". ...

delta5 replied 1 month, 1 week ago
Is it possible that he might be using the wrong bullets for 9mm?

rcmodel replied 1 month, 1 week ago
No. Both the the SIG P6 and probably the XD have very short leades designed for FMJ-RN military bullets. Truncated cone or JHP will hit the leade sooner then a RN, and need to be seated deeper until they don't. It is a very common problem with those and other guns with match chambers designed to work with RN bullets. IMO: The very best case guage made is the barrel out of your...

MichaelK replied 1 month, 1 week ago
In my personal experience, Lee taper crimping dies just don't do what they are supposed to do. In both 9mm and .45ACP I've had feeding problems that were traced back to the inadequate crimp performed by Lee dies. Solved all my problems by buying "real" taper crimping dies by Hornady. I still use my Lee dies for reloading, but always finish the rounds with a Hornady taper crimp now. I ...

Galil5.56 replied 1 month, 1 week ago
Have always used the barrel to correctly gauge ammo, and have never had it not work 100% of the time to tell me what I need to know. Lots of different barrels out there with lots of different chambers/leades, so you already have the best gauge IMO and experience. Beretta 92/M9 barrels tend to run wide on dimensions, and I have used bullets sized .359" in my M9, and customarily use them a ....

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
rcmodel
6
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-12 13:25:00)
Still, the SIG P6 in question is a German gun, made for German police & military, using FMJ-RN ammo. American Sporting Arms & Ammunition Manufactures Institute (SAAMI) specs didn't have anything to do with the chamber or leade dimensions. I'm here to tell you they have a shorter then normal leade, and TC or HP bullets with a longer full diameter extending past the case mouth have to be seated shorter to chamber in...
Deavis
6
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-12 14:20:00)
And never have I disagreed with your assessment of that specific weapon or your point in general. I'm pretty sure my statements regarding gaging have been clear from the beginning, let's not make more of it that necessary but we can always go get the CIP standard and find out if it is different from SAAMI for the 9mm. Even more interesting, we can go ask those Germans what standard they used when chambering and rifiling that pistol....
w00dc4ip
6
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I...
Published (2009-12-02 16:48:00)
So, after a few nights of manufacturing and a few trips to the range to test out my rounds, I think I've found my "temporary" formula: Winchester or Federal once-fired Brass: .748-.755" length Winchester Small Pistol Primers Berry's Plated HP 124gr 9mm (.355" width) Alliant Bullseye Powder: 3.8gr OAL: 1.080" +/- .003" Crimp Width: .378" This formula is the minimum powder...
RidgwayCO
4
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I...
Published (2009-11-14 01:18:00)
Nice job on your workup, w00dc4ip. Let us know how the second set shoots with your other 9mms. If you're not completely sold on the Berry's plated bullets, you can try Montana Gold's full metal jacketed (fmj - lead base is exposed) or completely metal jacketed (cmj - base is covered) bullets at very reasonable prices (bought in bulk). https://secure3.mooseweb.com/montana.../pricelist.tpl __________________ "A well...
jfh
2
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-11 19:30:00)
Thank you, Deavis. What publication is that; is it online? Have a link? added on edit: I found it; it is pdf page 29 in the online version of this manual , "ANSI / SAAMI Centerfire Pistol and Revolver" (Performance Standards Handbook). added on edit #2: I've just printed the page and will study it. It seems to me, however, that what we have for the ongoing discussion in this thread is this issue: What is the nature of...
Jim Watson
1
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-10 12:03:00)
If they won't go in the chamber, they won't shoot. It looks like you need some taper crimp on the case, at least eliminate the flare or close it down SLIGHTLY. If you stuck a bullet in the rifling, the OAL is too long. Seat the bullets and crimp to where the round will chamber FREELY and extract in one piece. Yes, shorter OAL will reduce working volume in the case and increase chamber pressure. That is what the boring fine print...
chris in va
1
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-10 12:42:00)
I had the same problem loading 124gr TC bullets. Initial OAL was 1.11 as suggested in my Lyman manual, but they wouldn't chamber in my CZ or HiPoint carbine. I ended up with 1.04oal with that particular bullet. And I agree about a taper crimp, really helps in my case.
F_L
1
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-10 12:37:00)
Use a case gauge or a barrel and see what the max length you can load to. I load 9mm for a Sig P6. Max length for this pistol is 1.065 or it will stick in the lands. All ready said but start at the lowest charge and work your way up. For 124 gr LRN I started at 3.4 gr bullseye and worked up to 3.8. Works good in the P6. Fred
delta5
1
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-10 13:33:00)
Is it possible that he might be using the wrong bullets for 9mm?
MichaelK
1
user's latest post:
FTF Question - what am I missing?
Published (2009-11-10 13:49:00)
In my personal experience, Lee taper crimping dies just don't do what they are supposed to do. In both 9mm and .45ACP I've had feeding problems that were traced back to the inadequate crimp performed by Lee dies. Solved all my problems by buying "real" taper crimping dies by Hornady. I still use my Lee dies for reloading, but always finish the rounds with a Hornady taper crimp now. I would not get histerical about...

Related threads on "THR":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "FTF Question - what am I missing?" on http://www.thehighroad.org. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "FTF Question - what am I missing?", located on the Message Board at http://www.thehighroad.org. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity