Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: Ever eaten wild mushrooms? should I be scared??

Started 1 year, 6 months ago by Hematite
The same advice goes for any food at all. Mushrooms are not especially dangerous. Fatal mushroom poisoning actually is not very common-- far less common than fatal food poisoning from eating E. coli or Salmonella contaminated meat or produce. The vast majority of 'bad' mushrooms produce nothing more than an upset gut and perhaps a nasty bout of vomiting. Of course there ARE lethally poisonous ...
Site: Chowhound Boards - CHOW  Chowhound Boards - CHOW - site profile
Forum: General Chowhounding Topics  General Chowhounding Topics - forum profile
Total authors: 14 authors
Total thread posts: 28 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: chow.com

Other posts in this thread:

mpalmer6c replied 1 year, 6 months ago
Depends on where you live, and the expertise of the pluckers.. Morels, I understand from Michigan friends, are easy to differentiate. Here on the West Coast, there seem to be fairly frequent stories about people who eat wild mushrooms and wind up on the critical list or worse. I pass.

BobB replied 1 year, 5 months ago
My wife is Russian and an avid mushroom hunter, as are most all the Russians we know (there is a huge emigre community here in my town). They grew up learning what to look for, and no one ever gets sick, they stick with the types they know (it helps that the woods here in New England are very similar to those near St. Petersburg where she grew up). I've learned to help her spot them - it's ...

Kelli2006 replied 1 year, 5 months ago
I learned how to ID wild mushrooms from my father and a HS biology teacher who liked to lecture in the 20 acre forest just outside the back doors of the school. It isn't easy to mistake a morel for the poisonous once you are familiar the markers, and the price of your knowledge can be quite tasty. Ive found wild chanterelles and even the very rare and succulent wild porcini on very rare ...

cassis replied 1 year, 5 months ago
Before it breaks through its egg shaped capsule, an juvenile amanita can look very much like a small puffball if the rain has washed off those crumbs on the cap. If you cut through it you see the embryonic curled up amanita instead of the solid interior of a puffball. So yes, you need to know them all under all conditions, as the stakes are pretty high.

PeterL replied 1 year, 5 months ago
Risk reward. What's the reward? Some good tasting mushroom. What's the risk? Death or life time health problem. You decide on whether the reward is worth the risk. I live in a city with a large number of eastern European immigrants, and each year one or two of them dies from eating poison mushrooms that they identify as safe in their home country.

viperlush replied 1 year, 5 months ago
<My husband says she grew up in Poland picking wild mushrooms with her greandmother and knows what she's doing.> Hopefully she is not using her knowledge of European mushrooms to identify American mushrooms... My freshmen year biology teacher told us that while he was getting his doctorate he would forage for food (bulbs, greens, 'shroom, etc.) He still did it and would bring random things ...

cassis replied 1 year, 5 months ago
The central market in Budapest has a table set up with two or three experts in white coats (at least the day I was there) who will identify mushrooms. Also pharmacies in France and Italy have posters in the window illustrating good and bad mushrooms, which makes sense because pharmacies double as emergency rooms and deliver first aid. Any mushroom with gills is problematic, since porcini, ...

Scargod replied 1 year, 5 months ago
It's a slow, agonizing death with a lot of rolling on the floor clenching your gut (and other horrible bodily functions gone bezerk), for days before you go.... I know. In my dreams, of course! We've bought lots of books and have gone out with experts and after a while we find that there are just a few shrooms that are good to eat, at any one time of the year, under a certain kind of tree, etc. ...

Passadumkeg replied 1 year, 5 months ago
But I hear the colors one sees just before death are awesome!

PeterL replied 1 year, 5 months ago
OP is not out foraging for mushroom. He is trying to decide whether it's safe to eat mushroom foraged by someone else who claims that she did it back in her home country.

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
Scargod
5
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-07 13:19:00)
Chanterelles will never be found on grassy areas where no trees are present. http://www.mushroom-collecting.com/mu...
Passadumkeg
5
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-07 14:19:00)
Jack 'O Lanterns grow on rotting stumps.
PeterL
3
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-07 19:05:00)
Well good for you. Positive: good tasting food. Negative, liver transplant or death. In my book the negative far out weights the positive.
coll
3
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-07 16:08:00)
I had a feeling he was lucky, not knowledgable.
cassis
2
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2008-06-14 11:33:00)
Before it breaks through its egg shaped capsule, an juvenile amanita can look very much like a small puffball if the rain has washed off those crumbs on the cap. If you cut through it you see the embryonic curled up amanita instead of the solid interior of a puffball. So yes, you need to know them all under all conditions, as the stakes are pretty high.
Pollo
2
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-06 19:16:00)
If she learned which mushrooms to look for in Poland then she know what to pick. There is maybe 5-8 types that are v. common and popular in Europe (Poland) and these are quite distinct and not that difficult to distinguish. There is a large number of mushroom types in Europe and North America that are identical but ther are some varieties that are unknown to me and the rule I follow is that if I don't know it or it doesn't look...
viperlush
1
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2008-06-14 19:20:00)
&lt;My husband says she grew up in Poland picking wild mushrooms with her greandmother and knows what she's doing.&gt; Hopefully she is not using her knowledge of European mushrooms to identify American mushrooms... My freshmen year biology teacher told us that while he was getting his doctorate he would forage for food (bulbs, greens, 'shroom, etc.) He still did it and would bring random things he picked for us to taste.I...
eartha
1
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2008-06-15 14:58:00)
I grew up in the Thumb of Michigan and was trained by my Mom and Dad which mushrooms were safe and those that were not, or those my parents didn't fully understand and avoided. The poisonous fungi were called Toadstools and we were taught to look at the underside to determine whether eatable. Even so, my parents were extremely cautious, not allowing some fungus I later found out was highly yummy --like the so-called Snow-Balls. I prefer...
Goddesslikewoman
1
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2009-11-06 12:18:00)
by the sound of it, the mushrooms that yourecieved pickled are called &quot;slippery jacks&quot; they're a good mushroom, and they usually grow in glades where there are some small pine trees. i myself have picked them from the age of 4 on. they're NOT poisonous NOR are they &quot;magic&quot;. the beauty of the slippery jack, is that there is no poisonous counterpart (i.e. a mushroom by simialar look, smell and...
Hematite
1
user's latest post:
Ever eaten wild mushrooms?...
Published (2008-06-11 19:01:00)
The same advice goes for any food at all. Mushrooms are not especially dangerous. Fatal mushroom poisoning actually is not very common-- far less common than fatal food poisoning from eating E. coli or Salmonella contaminated meat or produce. The vast majority of 'bad' mushrooms produce nothing more than an upset gut and perhaps a nasty bout of vomiting. Of course there ARE lethally poisonous mushrooms, just as there are deadly...

Related threads on "Chowhound Boards - CHOW":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "Ever eaten wild mushrooms? should I be scared??" on http://www.chow.com. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Ever eaten wild mushrooms? should I be scared??", located on the Message Board at http://www.chow.com. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity