Thread: Broken Studs Caused By Aftermarket Wheels?
Started 1 month, 2 weeks ago by mxmike27
My truck is a stock 06 2500 Megacab 5.9 4X4. After running my stock wheels for about 18 months with no issues I bought some American Racing, Fuel, aluminum wheels, from Tire warehouse. I had BFG 315s mounted. Shortly after, I began breaking wheel studs. I broke a total of 26 over the next 18 months. Tire warehouse paid for replacement, admitting it must be the wheels, though they didnt know why. ...
I don't have an answer for you, but it is interesting that you bring this up. I was at a dealer two nights ago looking at an 06 Mega Cab that had aftermarket wheels on it. I passed on the deal cause half of the lug nuts were broken off......I know the torque specifications are different depending on the material the wheel is made of. Maybe these aftermarket rims are a harder material and the ...
I don't know about aftermarket wheels but on my stock wheels my mechanic
friend rotated tires and used air gun to tighten. Shortly after I was
hearing clicking on turns. Checked lugs and many had loosened. After buying
torque wrench and torquing to factory specs all good. I read that unlike
steel wheels aluminum needs to be done right being different metal. Maybe
when some are loose the others ...
Somebody covered this a while back. There are retaining washers on every
other stud (that's why half of the studs on the MC you saw were busted).
The factory wheels have recesses built in to accommodate them and
aftermarket doesn't. Knock off the retaining washers and get some good
studs and you should be set!
I have had about 8 different sets of rims on my truck, most aftermarket and some of the retaining clips still on never any issue. They are all off now, but I HIGHLY doubt they have anything to do with it.
I think the biggest thing is people using impacts on them, and don't know what they are doing. Don't know how many times when I go to take off tires some vehicles i've had to stand on the ...
The shop that replaced the studs took off those retaining clips. He thought those were the problem because the aftermarket wheels dont have a recess for them. The lugs were first torqued to 140, then the next times they were torqued to 120.
Mike
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveB.inVa
Somebody covered this a while back. There are retaining washers on every other stud (that's why half of the studs on the MC you saw were busted). The factory wheels have recesses built in to accommodate them and aftermarket doesn't. Knock off the retaining washers and get some good studs and you ...
26 broken studs in 18 months!!!!! Ouch.
Something is definitely wrong. I'm just wondering if they are metric 8 bolt wheels instead of our 8 bolt pattern? I know the Fords went to metric 8 bolt. Will those wheels go on but with the studs not centered in the holes?
Either that or extreme overtightening. I'm careful no to overtighten mine and 140 ft lbs seems high to begin with. ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveB.inVa
Somebody covered this a while back. There are retaining washers on every other stud (that's why half of the studs on the MC you saw were busted). The factory wheels have recesses built in to accommodate them and aftermarket doesn't. Knock off the retaining washers and get some good studs and you ...
Quote: Originally Posted by Fisherguy the consensus is our trucks are lug-centric The consensus is 100% WRONG! The information you are presenting here as "consensus" is not only wrong, it is also life threatening. It is your choice to ignore accepted engineering practice and to drive a vehicle with a butchered wheel installation. Ever consider if you kill another party on the highway, they might win a lawsuit because of the...
Quote: Originally Posted by RowJ Ghenges - you give a whole new definition to the word "condesending"! Just when did excellent valid experienced information become "condesending" (BTW; condesending is properly spelled: condescending ). Began posting here because it was apparent despite millions of posts there was scant relevant information. Basically the same tired information passed from poster to poster...
Quote: Originally Posted by Fisherguy Anyone got a picture of these retaining washers? I've had my wheels off lotsa times, don't remember seeing any clips..? I've never ran aftermarket wheels and the last time I had mine off I didn't pay any attention. I just remember reading about it on here. Seemed to help the guys situation though. Here is a link to the post with pictures....
The nuts are not drilled through, theyre capped. I wonder if the stud is bottoming out on the cap of the nut just before the torque value is met. And thanx for all the replys. Mike
Quote: Originally Posted by ghenges 4500 actual pounds on the front axle empty? Sounds absolutely goofy. I weighed my truck with me and full fuel and then did it with just the front axle on the scale. Total weight = 7460 lbs Front axle = 4476 lbs 60% of total weight on the front (due to the cummins) makes sense to me. And that's just a 4x4, 2500! RJ
Quote: Originally Posted by torquefan As I took the wheel off, my eye caught a sticker on the back of it that said "max weight 2400 Lbs." I was a little shocked that someone would have sold these wheels to put on a 2500 truck, and also that there would be a market at all for an 8 bolt wheel that light. So what do you think each corner of the truck weighs? I know the front corners weigh more then the rear. If the corners do...
Quote: Originally Posted by Fisherguy 2400 is not enough, the front axle on mine weighs 4500 empty. According to my door sticker front axle is 5200 pounds, rear is 6200. Exactly. Not much point in buying the 'E' rated tires our trucks require (rated for 3042 LBS. each) if you are putting them on those wheels.
Quote: Originally Posted by RowJ I spent a lot of time looking at after market wheels. Three things caused me to say NO!! 1-What you mention above is common. Most after market wheels are in the 2200 to 2400 lb range. Just not enough saftey margin for me! 2-I've seen a few of these after market wheels crack spokes when hauling medium trailer loads. 3-My local tire guru, in business over 30 yrs, told me he has seen all brands of after...
Related threads on "Dodge Diesel - Diesel Truck Resource Forums":
Thread profile page for "Broken Studs Caused By Aftermarket Wheels?" on http://www.dieseltruckresource.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Broken Studs Caused By Aftermarket Wheels?", located on the Message Board at http://www.dieseltruckresource.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity