Started 1 month, 4 weeks ago by pseudotriton ruber ruber
Par un bizarre coincidence, as Pynchon puts it, in this thread where Even Sven tells her sad tale of heartbreak, and where I offer sage counsel informed by many another such sad tale of my own, I got my own heart stomped a few hours after posting my advice to her. My new GF, of about a month, whom I had completely flipped over in that month, phoned me up to say she wasn't feeling what I felt ...
Don't post that note. Don't contact her.
Our brains tell us weird, addict-like things at these times; they think she did it because she's looking for a grand gesture; or that not contacting her will make her think you were only in it for one thing; or we latch onto the outcomes of romantic comedies; or we think we can negotiate affairs of the heart.
I speak from painful experience when ...
Heh. I pulled this one too, but with more tears and less dignity than a note.
She's gonna shoot you down. You'll lose one more shred of dignity. I think I was one my way to the possibility of some sort of reconciliation, but ruined it by showing how desperate I really was for him. Now he's seen my weakness and hardend his heart. I don't think I'll ever be able to change that.
Leave it...
Don't do it! My best guess is she's either going to see you as a "pig" ('He just wants someone to screw!') or figure it's out of desperation and try even harder to push you away.
I'm not an expert on relationships.
But I would strongly suggest you don't contact her for a while.
You're feeling miserable (and no doubt she is too) and that's the worst time to try and set up a sexual relationship (let alone a 'no-strings' one).
If time heals the wounds a bit and you meet up again in a civil way, you can then consider whether to mention your idea.
pseudotriton ruber ruber replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
Sorry, folks, that note went out almost as soon as I finished writing it. Now, it just remains to speculate, as I check my incoming e-mail every hour or so. I know, it made me sound like a pig and had very little chance of getting the response I want, but I'd pretty much lost her entirely anyway, and this way, there's still a chance I could get some of what I want. But as I'm hearing you all, no ...
Why are you so sure you can handle a FWB relationship with her? She's the one who broke up with you, and therefore is less likely to have the emotional attachments that tends to get in the way of these things. You, as the person who was dumped, are basically begging to be put in a disadvantaged position.
In my opinion, FWB's between two people who used to date each other only works if ...
pseudotriton ruber ruber replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
Quote:
Originally Posted by you with the face
Think of your pride as well.
Ain't got none. I actually think I'm rational enough to deal with my emotional issues okay--it's going to be painful, either way, in a FWB relationship or all by myself, to adjust to the news that she isn't all gaga over me and never will be...
Great sex isn't all that great when you're in an unrequited love situation. You may be able to ride the orgasmatron for a while, but sooner or later, you're going to want more, and you'll probably say so, which will put the orgasmatron into a tail-spin. Worlds will collide. Good luck though...gotta hand it to you for following your...heart.
pseudotriton ruber ruber replied 1 month, 4 weeks ago
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjimm
Bear in mind, too, that many of the reasons given in a breakup are spurious, designed to cushion the blow for the other person.
That's certainly true. The last woman I broke up with (a short while ago, to clear my decks for my latest ex-GF) I had all sorts of bedroom issues with--...
Thank you, Sven --I wish you the best, too, but am pretty sure that such an attractive, charming, adventurous woman like you needs very little luck. I just know you'll meet the right guy for you soon if not today. You're just too good not to find someone who's good for you.
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber She claims she wants to protect my tender feelings, but I'm all "I ain't got none. Let ME worry about my tender feelings, okay? If I am able to keep my emotions and my feelings to myself, and deal, why are you so concerned?" You sound just like a guy who I used to date who said the almost same thing to me when I turned down a FWB arrangement with him. It pissed...
Thanks. I'm glad this last one is gone for good. He's clearly lacking something essential as a person, and it's better that I got some small heartbreak instead of whatever truly evil stuff he'd be dishing out later in the game. But yeah, I remain hopeful that once I am ready- once I am in a stable place and open to it- I'll find what I need. We all deserve love, yeah? God willing we will find what we are looking for!
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber All we lost was pride, dignity, self-respect, the respect of our exes, the esteem of the Teeming Millions, and a whole lot of hours of sleep. Big deal, right? On the plus side, you didn't loose the esteem of anyone here who is self aware enough to recognize that at some point, they've made, or been tempted to make, similarly spectacularly unwise compromises to hold onto something...
Many years ago I broke someone's heart, and she agreed to FWB. I said "look, this has no emotional component" and she concurred verbally - but her heart didn't. I ended up breaking her heart all over again, only much worse.
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber Do you guys just disapprove of FWB generally? I think this might be why FWB was invented--I get to gradually work on recognizing the reality that she just ain't THAT into me, meanwhile I get laid rather sublimely, until she takes up with a new guy, and I go, "Okay, I can deal with that at this point" instead of staying up all night thinking about her with a new guy...
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber ...at 8:35 PM last night, I thought I had a great GF and a pretty sweet life; at 8:36 I felt like I'd had a train hit me. I'm still trying to get my mind around that sudden change, and I'm a little better now, but only a little. I'm hoping next week, I'll be a little more philosophical, and next month I'll start to recover, but it's going to take time. I...
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber All we lost was pride, dignity, self-respect, the respect of our exes, the esteem of the Teeming Millions, and a whole lot of hours of sleep. Big deal, right? It is so frustrating* to have absolutely no control over a situation when the impact on you is so enormous. (Realizing that "frustrating" doesn't even begin to express the emotions involved.) Nothing useful to...
Quote: Originally Posted by Surly Chick I think it's for the best that she turned down your FWB request, PRR. You would have just ended up getting hurt more in the end. It's going to be a tough month or so for you but you'll bounce back. We all do. Slee -I followed the K saga from the beginning and was skeptical about her from the get go. She sounded like a head case and you're better off without her. I know that's...
Quote: Originally Posted by pseudotriton ruber ruber Still seems a little extreme to me to go from the Monogamous LT Model to nothing at all, without trying "Dude, can you dial your freaking expectations down a bit? Else I'm outta here" first, but maybe that's going to remain a mystery to me. Honestly, I agree with you on this. Really, it seems quite reasonable that a gradual weaning off would be better -- but...
B. B. King - Broken Heart Lyrics:... B. B. King - Broken Heart Lyrics: http://wikilyrics.net/song/75733/B.-B.-King---Broken-Heart-Lyrics # B # B # King # # Broken # Heart # Lyrics
Thread profile page for "Broken Heart, PRR-style" on http://www.straightdope.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Broken Heart, PRR-style", located on the Message Board at http://www.straightdope.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity