Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Thread: Am I Required by Law To Show My Receipt When I'm Leaving Wal-Mart?

Started 3 months, 1 week ago by Gus_Handsome
I go through the check-out at Wal-Mart, pay for my purchases, and as I'm heading out the door to the parking lot, a Wal-Mart "Greeter" intercepts me and says "Sir, I'd like to see your receipt for your purchases." (before I leave the store) Am I legally obliged to show and have her go through my purchases or can I say "no thanks" and keep walking? Thanks Gus PS--> I always ...
Site: Straight Dope Message Board  Straight Dope Message Board - site profile
Forum: General Questions  General Questions - forum profile
Total authors: 25 authors
Total thread posts: 43 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: straightdope.com

Other posts in this thread:

Covered_In_Bees! replied 3 months, 1 week ago
No you are not legally required to stop and fork over your receipt. Yes you can say "No thanks." and keep walking. Though if they truly believe you stole something they are allowed to get security, who does have the authority to hold you there while they inspect your goods. I believe. The greeters are not security personnel, so they have no true authority over you but have the ability ...

Magiver replied 3 months, 1 week ago
The answer to that is: "YES, I'll show it to you but only at the refund desk".

Francis Vaughan replied 3 months, 1 week ago
The answer will vary all over the world, but typically no. Nor does security have any additional rights. They are just ordinary people in a uniform. Nor do they typically have a right to inspect bags, even when there is a sign saying you accept that as a condition of entry. (This one probably depends greatly upon local case law, and may vary quite considerably.) Here in Oz, the one thing they...

Markxxx replied 3 months, 1 week ago
I've only been asked one time for my receipt at Walmart and that is when I bought a TV set. Though the box clearly had a "paid" sticker on it, the greeter asked to see my receipt then let me through. I usually buy food and pick up my meds at Walmart, so I rarely have any large items and I've never been asked nor has anyone prompted me to show my receipt. I see them do it for larger ...

garygnu replied 3 months, 1 week ago
Quote: Originally Posted by Francis Vaughan ...Nor do they typically have a right to inspect bags, even when there is a sign saying you accept that as a condition of entry... Club stores in the US, such as Costco, that are not open to the public without membership, can and do include receipt inspection as part of ...

hellpaso replied 3 months, 1 week ago
Depending on my mood, I have been known to tell them "Sure--I just stole $300 worth of food, Fuck-head". They then look scared and back off. I find it stupid and insulting to have some pathetic soul working for minimum wage to confront me on whether or not I've paid for my items. The items are obviously packaged and I have a receipt in my hand. I've never stolen anything, but wouldn't a thief...

IAmNotSpartacus replied 3 months, 1 week ago
Quote: Originally Posted by garygnu Club stores in the US, such as Costco, that are not open to the public without membership, can and do include receipt inspection as part of the membership agreement. This is correct as far as I know. The fastest way to make the twits at the non-membership stores leave you ...

IAmNotSpartacus replied 3 months, 1 week ago
Quote: Originally Posted by hellpaso Depending on my mood, I have been known to tell them "Sure--I just stole $300 worth of food, Fuck-head". This is a pretty silly thing to do IMO, when you say this you have essentially given them free probable cause to detain you until the police arrive to sort the matter out ...

Skammer replied 3 months, 1 week ago
I don't get it -- why is everyone so offended to be asked to show a receipt? I'm glad they're trying to find shoplifters, it keeps prices down. I'd be concerned if they didn't bother.

Kobal2 replied 3 months, 1 week ago
Quote: Originally Posted by hellpaso Depending on my mood, I have been known to tell them "Sure--I just stole $300 worth of food, Fuck-head". They then look scared and back off. I find it stupid and insulting to have some pathetic soul working for minimum wage to confront me on whether or not I've paid for my items. The items are ...

 

Top contributing authors

Name
Posts
whorfin
7
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 15:06:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Rumor_Watkins I routinely shop at wally world I have been asked to show a receipt maybe 3 times It has never lasted more 5 seconds I have never had to wait in line to get my receipt checked they do not make demands or interjections - they ask politely now, granted I don't go in on fridays when welfare disbursements are made, and I don't go on saturdays when the majority of people shop, either, so...
Bearflag70
4
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 14:59:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by pan1 The Greeter likewise is not legally obligated to allow store merchandise to leave the store without proof it's been paid for. ... They can assume the goods in your possession are theirs until proof otherwise is shown. They can keep the cart and it's contents and let you go. Ditto, store bags you are carrying. Your purse, they can't touch without formal accusations of a crime and a warrant or...
Rumor_Watkins
4
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 15:11:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by whorfin Nice dodge. I didn't ask you, and don't really care about what you do when they're polite and it doesn't take long. Most people do the same thing. What I'm asking is whether you would still show your receipt if the checker was rude and demanding, or if it took a substantial amount of time. I have contended that I would not, unlike the situation with a nice greeter and no...
t-bonham@scc.net
3
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 13:25:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Bearflag70 I'd hate to see what happens when someone asks you to please pass the salt during dinner. Don't be ridiculous. Do you really think the friends & family I am dining with are the same as some Wal-Mart drone I have never seen before?
Kinthalis
2
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 14:45:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by pan1 No, you are not legally obligated to show your receipt as you leave Wal-Mart. The Greeter likewise is not legally obligated to allow store merchandise to leave the store without proof it's been paid for. I'm fairly certain that this is incorrect, but I would appreciate a cite showing otherwise.
Markxxx
2
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 15:11:00)
I can see why people hate the practice. It's like saying: "I walk into the store, I pay for my goods, you issue me a receipt and STILL you think I'm stealing." Of course the store will check everyone so it doesn't come into a law suit for racial (or other types of) profiling. Here's another example, not quite the same thing but similar. I worked in a hotel where all the employees had to walk past security...
garygnu
2
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 13:03:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by t-bonham@scc.net They started it -- I was just calmly walking out after making my purchases when they rudely interrupted me... Do you consider the very act of asking to check your receipt to be rude? The vast majority of the time for me they are quite polite about it.
IAmNotSpartacus
2
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 11:20:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by hellpaso Depending on my mood, I have been known to tell them "Sure--I just stole $300 worth of food, Fuck-head". This is a pretty silly thing to do IMO, when you say this you have essentially given them free probable cause to detain you until the police arrive to sort the matter out since you are freely admitting to a crime. And you certainly aren't making yourself look like the upstanding...
Kimmy_Gibbler
1
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 11:46:00)
The question is not: Am I legally required to show my receipt when leaving Wal-Mart? It is rather: Can Wal-Mart legally detain me for failing to show a receipt upon request? At common law, there existed the shopkeeper's privilege. This authorized a store proprietor (or it's agents, whether called "Security Personnel" or "Greeters") to detain and investigate (but not to search) a person on or...
Gus_Handsome
1
user's latest post:
Am I Required by Law To Show My...
Published (2009-09-28 01:38:00)
I go through the check-out at Wal-Mart, pay for my purchases, and as I'm heading out the door to the parking lot, a Wal-Mart "Greeter" intercepts me and says "Sir, I'd like to see your receipt for your purchases." (before I leave the store) Am I legally obliged to show and have her go through my purchases or can I say "no thanks" and keep walking? Thanks Gus PS--> I always...

Related threads on "Straight Dope Message Board":

Related threads on other sites:

Thread profile page for "Am I Required by Law To Show My Receipt When I'm Leaving Wal-Mart?" on http://www.straightdope.com. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "Am I Required by Law To Show My Receipt When I'm Leaving Wal-Mart?", located on the Message Board at http://www.straightdope.com. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity