I always have my Leatherman Surge on my belt and my Kershaw Speedsafe in my pocket. Then a small credit card survival tool with a nice knuckle blade in my wallet.
If forced to pick one, I'd obviously choose my Leatherman. But maybe a SHTF blade should be better at prying, non-reflective, etc...
What are your thoughts on a good knife to have for SHTF?
Thanks!
-...
As an all-around multi-tool, a Leatherman is hard to beat. But thats what it is...a multi-tool, not primarily a knife.
Knives are like guns. You can't expect one knife to do every task you ask of knives, although there are many that could get you through MOST tasks you need a knife for.
Depends on where you are and what you're doing. If I was in say, the amazon, I'd want a machette with a serated back edge, if I was in the city, I'd want a multi tool. As a hiker in MO, I carry a CRKT ABC Operator as my EDC and my hiking knive with a a gerber Chameleon, and a CRKT M16 in my pack.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tc556guy
As an all-around multi-tool, a Leatherman is hard to beat. But thats what it is...a multi-tool, not primarily a knife.
Knives are like guns. You can't expect one knife to do every task you ask of knives, although there are many that could get you through MOST tasks you need a knife for....
You're not going to baton a leatherman to make kindling. You need a real, full tang, fixed blade knife. Not some jumbo crocodile dundee blade - but a real outdoors knife.
Buck 119 is a good, cheap option.
Gerber LMF II is a good deal for the price and strong.
Any version of the Air Force Survival / Kabar family.
There are a ton of higher end knives - Scrap yard, Busse, etc etc etc....
Quote:
Originally Posted by paperairplane
You're not going to baton a leatherman to make kindling. You need a real, full tang, fixed blade knife. Not some jumbo crocodile dundee blade - but a real outdoors knife.
Buck 119 is a good, cheap option.
Gerber LMF II is a good deal for the price and strong.
Any version of the...
Quote:
Originally Posted by emt1581
Good point. Seems like a Leatherman could do many tasks and some pretty well. But the important thing to talk about is what it CAN'T do. If a Leatherman is good for everything but prying...maybe a Leatherman and a Glock (or some other knife that can pry) would be a good setup for SHTF.
...
Batoning is using a knife to split wood when you don't have a wedge, axe, hatchet, etc.
Simply place the knife on the wood and then use a small log, rock, etc to hammer the knife into the wood and split it into smaller pieces for kindling.
I think the term is from using a 'baton' on the back of the blade.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tc556guy
What exactly do you see yourself prying in a perceived survival situation? If you want a pry tool, keep a prybar in your trunk. Any knife is a poor pry tool given the short overall length; you simply can't get enough torque and you're gonna snap even the best blades if you try....
Quote:
Originally Posted by emt1581
What would I need to pry? Honestly, I have no clue. Maybe a locked cabinet (wood or metal) for medical or other supplies. Maybe a glove compartment. But whatever it is, the task will most likely be in a city/urban dwelling. I'm not sure what prying I'd have to do that I could use a knife for in...
Quote: Originally Posted by Dogbite I noticed it, but nothing was said to the person--not sure if he has ever gotten crap about it. I've noticed a lot of places that would bring hell down for concealing a fixed blade have almost nothing to say about it if its carried openly. Seems to be the concealed part that gets em.
This is worse than caliber wars. I could care less what makers mark is on a knife so long as it is quality made from quality materials. The function(s) it must perform dictate the form it will take. For example, deep in the amazon jungle a $5 machete will be better suited than a $200 folder. I think it'd be better to talk about things that most brands have that matter to everyone. Materials Fixed vs. Folder Type of Metal Type(s) of edge...
Quote: Originally Posted by gimmejr Id also check out The Cutting Edge section here on Glock Talk. Well sure, sure...then they can convince me to blow $400-$700 on a Busse..no thanks! -Emt1581
Some people cannot carry a fixed blade due to legal reasons, like you mention, others have no reasonable way to comfortably and properly conceal a fixed blade of adequate size. Though I have to say I really want to pick up a RAT Izula. Not big, but a fixed blade almost anybody could reasonably carry on a daily basis. Or a becker necker maybe
Quote: Originally Posted by TheLastBoyscout Man ya'll can say what you want but my Leatherman Supertool goes everywhere I go. I should write a short list/story some day of all the jams it has gotten me out of and how useful it is. I just can't see being without one. You can do some prying with one. Had a bottle of gas at work the other day, you know like welders use, and the top would not come loose as it was rusty and over...
Wow. Too bad you guys don't live in a free state like Massachusetts where anyone, permit or not, can carry a folding or fixed blade, concealed or not, length not a factor. I'm sure you're allowed ninja stars and nun chucks tho.
Quote: Originally Posted by Tim808 31f20 - Could you post a video of cutting thru a 2x4 with an 8" knife in 7 seconds....that must be a BA knife. In the cold steel machete video, it takes about 45 seconds to cut thru what looks like a 2x4. Tim - check pm's.
Quote: Originally Posted by G29Reload so long as they're Striders and not knockoffs , I'd use them first and not bother with the Buck. Imitators peddling junk lookalikes started popping up a few years ago. The're both the "real deal", because I don't buy crap! Best Wishes! Pecos Bill out.
Thread profile page for "A good SHTF blade?" on http://www.glocktalk.com.
This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "A good SHTF blade?", located on the Message Board at http://www.glocktalk.com.
This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity