Thread: 2.23 - Live Together, Die Alone

[QUOTE=lizziefitz]Hey, you gotta have standards. But does Jack--and his man-boobs--count in that total? [/QUOTE] No, it does not. It must include some combination of any two of the following: Sayid, Sawyer, Jin, or Eko. And what a glorious opening: they provided the required combination.    

[b]1st Break:[/b] Thank you, Lost writers, for shirtless Sawyer and Sayid, but yet no shirtless Jack. Thank you, thank you, thank you. OMG IT'S DESMOND (would have been an effective shock had I not been spoiled/the trailers not given it away.) [i]Is[/i] it a trap? The three guys who are physically a threat, save Jin and Eko, are now on that boat... [b]2d Break:[/b] Jesus Christ, Jack, listen to Sayid. He knows what he's talking...

Actually, Sayid's plan was a pretty terrible one. Why assume that Michael's telling the truth about the Others' camp on the beach? Why assume that you can arrange a rendezvous, even with the helpful black smoke, over unfamiliar territory and at an undetermined time with no means of communication? The Others would see the smoke too, yes? And then have a good chance to ambush our two groups of Losties separately. A better plan:...

[QUOTE=heatdamaged] The Claire/Charlie kiss is receiving attention at a couple of fan sites and even garnered the dismay of Ausiello. While some of the fan attention seems to be nothing more than ship issues, I find myself agreeing that the fireside scene was forced and unrealistic. I could care less about the romantic issues, but Claire's actions seemed out-of-character and really just felt like sloppy writing....

The Claire/Charlie kiss is receiving attention at a couple of fan sites and even garnered the dismay of Ausiello. While some of the fan attention seems to be nothing more than ship issues, I find myself agreeing that the fireside scene was forced and unrealistic. I could care less about the romantic issues, but Claire's actions seemed out-of-character and really just felt like sloppy writing. Did I miss...

/shallow fan girl:  Shirtless Sawyer and Sayid = \end shallow fan girl\ Another plus = no man boobs!! I was disappointed by Hurley's reaction (or lack thereof) when he found out Michael had offed Libby.  Maybe it's a good thing he didn't have a gun after all.  I found the trek to be rather boring.  P. S. Thanks Jack(ass), you're a great leader.  "I wouldn't have brought...

The morning here at the office was devoted to discussing this episode, although I doubt if it was with the official blessing of management.   I doubt that it matters but it seemed to be about a 50 50 split over the the best finale evah and meh.  After all, tv is not a democracy in the mileage department.   I fell into the meh camp.  Despite the shirtlessness.  Maybe because it was...

Yes Kate, the massive bright light and loud noise was faked. What, did Locke make another whistle quickly and blow it real hard?