My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix | Thread profile

Thread profile page for "USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix" on http://www.topix.com/forum/med. This report page is a snippet summary view from a single thread "USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix", located on the Message Board at http://www.topix.com/forum/med. This thread profile page shows the thread statistics for: Total Authors, Total Thread Posts, and Thread Activity, which are reported in a table below. Additional thread profile information is also shown in the following ways:

1) Top Contributing Authors
2) Related Threads on "eBay Auctions"
3) Related Threads on Other Sites

Warning: These statistics are generated using 'best efforts' and can experience delays and reporting errors at times. Please note that such statistics do not constitute a thread's popularity and/or exact posting volumes at any given reporting period.

Title: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix
Site: Medicine Forum - Topix  Medicine Forum - Topix - site profile
Forum: med  med - forum profile
Total authors: 11 authors
Total thread posts: 17 posts
Thread activity: no new posts during last week
Domain info for: topix.com

Thread posts in USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix:

1. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Eric_Johnson
"An Indiana University study found that after a countywide smoking ban was implemented, hospital admissions for heart attacks dropped 70 percent for non-smokers, but not for smokers." 70%!!!!!!!!! I believe this is the first study that discriminates between smokers and non-smokers with regards heart attacks. A 70% drop in heart attack admissions in non-smokers coinciding with the introduction...
Size: 513 bytes
Customize:  Customize "USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
2. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by enough
Anonymouse wrote: <quoted text> Poor Mike Siegel seems to have lost friends in the public health area and is now cozy with some strange smokers' rights loons. Take note that the propaganda that Justined cut and pasted is from that strange forces.com site. So a sample size of 22 is fine? Or is it only if it shows a difference that you agree with? Good job of attacking the messenger. ...
Size: 557 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 1</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
3. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Justined
The Rest of the Story by DR. MICHAEL SIEGEL To be blunt, this study is crappy and its conclusions are completely invalid. This study would never have passed scrutiny with me had I been asked to review it. In fact, the results of the study fail to support the paper's conclusion. While the press release sounds quite impressive, if you take the time to read the actual study, you'll find that the ...
Size: 2,252 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 2</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
4. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by MRab2
Eric, we've been seeing similar studies come out for a while, beginning, I believe, with the Helena study. They've all been debunked. The one in Scotland, you know, the one where the results were released but the study never was, was just shot full of holes by the offical figures that covered ALL of Scotland and not just a few well selected hospitals. Another one in the US was compared with the...
Size: 874 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 3</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
5. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by just candid
DryCow wrote: PU! Such blatant BS Welcome back Indian lady,we have missed you and your lengthy, caustic comments. LOL Keep enjoying life and have a great Thanksgiving !
Size: 303 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 4</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
6. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Smoke Free
Justined wrote: The Rest of the Story by DR. MICHAEL SIEGEL To be blunt, this study is crappy and its conclusions are completely invalid. This study would never have passed scrutiny with me had I been asked to review it. In fact, the results of the study fail to support the paper's conclusion. While the press release sounds quite impressive, if you take the time to read the actual study, ...
Size: 2,777 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 5</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
7. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Kent
Smoke Free is a F'n Quack. He talks out of both ends. Nobody with any authority would ever listen to him. He has gone off the deep end and is now considered a fanatic at best. He's like a Cult Leader, anti-smokers are desperate and he sees the stench coming in from these goons and loving it. Soon he'll be serving a special road apple flavored Kool-Aide, look out anti-smokers he's looking to buy a...
Size: 443 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 6</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
8. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Smoke Stack
More BS not worth my time...
Size: 28 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 7</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
9. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by DryCow
PU! Such blatant BS
Size: 25 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 8</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
10. 
Started 1 year ago (2007-11-20 00:00:00)  by Anonymouse
Smoke Free wrote: <quoted text> MICHAEL SIEGEL is a F'n Quack. He talks out of both ends. A few years ago people with authority would listen to him, but he has gone off the deep end and is now considered a fanatic at best. He's like a Cult Leader, smokers are desperate and he sees the money coming in from these loons and loving it. Soon he'll be serving a special tobacco flavored Kool-...
Size: 818 bytes
Customize:  Customize "<b>Reply 9</b>: USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix :: med :: Medicine Forum - Topix"
 

Top contributing authors for USA: Study Finds That Heart Attacks In Non-smokers Decreased With Smoking Ban - Topix

Name
Posts
enough
4
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-26 00:00:00)
enough wrote: &lt;quoted text&gt; An 3.5x increase in artery lesions when mice are switched from normal diet to the diet including alcohol doesn't exactly jibe with Dr. Bailey's assertion that &quot;moderate alcohol consumption is commonly thought to be cardioprotective&quot; - the increased risk from +alcohol leads to 50% more arterial lesions than +SHS (2.3x). Enough with the drive-by postings, Mouse. You posted...
Justined
3
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-27 04:42:20)
CONTINUED: There have been several other initiatives designed to reduce heart attacks in Scotland recently, and any or all might also have played a part. If we look at all heart attacks, rather than just emergency admissions, the fall last year according to the official data was slightly smaller again - about 7%- against falls in the past three years on this measure typically of about 4%. Rise and fall Scotland's deputy chief medical...
Anonymouse
2
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-23 00:00:00)
Here's another interesting study on the damage done by second hand smoke damaging the heart. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,312600,00...
Bill Hannegan
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-23 00:00:00)
An interesting letter in BMJ on heart attack studies: http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/328/7452/...
Eric_Johnson
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
&quot;An Indiana University study found that after a countywide smoking ban was implemented, hospital admissions for heart attacks dropped 70 percent for non-smokers, but not for smokers.&quot; 70%!!!!!!!!! I believe this is the first study that discriminates between smokers and non-smokers with regards heart attacks. A 70% drop in heart attack admissions in non-smokers coinciding with the introduction of new smoking regulations? Darn...
MRab2
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
Eric, we've been seeing similar studies come out for a while, beginning, I believe, with the Helena study. They've all been debunked. The one in Scotland, you know, the one where the results were released but the study never was, was just shot full of holes by the offical figures that covered ALL of Scotland and not just a few well selected hospitals. Another one in the US was compared with the figures from a neighbouring state that...
Smoke Stack
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
More BS not worth my time...
DryCow
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
PU! Such blatant BS
just candid
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
DryCow wrote: PU! Such blatant BS Welcome back Indian lady,we have missed you and your lengthy, caustic comments. LOL Keep enjoying life and have a great Thanksgiving !
Smoke Free
1
user's latest post:
USA: Study Finds That Heart...
Published (2007-11-20 00:00:00)
Justined wrote: The Rest of the Story by DR. MICHAEL SIEGEL To be blunt, this study is crappy and its conclusions are completely invalid. This study would never have passed scrutiny with me had I been asked to review it. In fact, the results of the study fail to support the paper's conclusion. While the press release sounds quite impressive, if you take the time to read the actual study, you'll find that the sweeping conclusion that...