Fadak Contradictory Claim. | Thread profile

QUOTE (amilcar1976 @ May 10 2008, 10:30 PM) the hadith about the prophet not leaving inheritence is weak and rejected brother ,even though we have this hadith in our books of hadith , it's a hadith narrated by sunni narrators secondly this hadith contradicts the koran Why Imam Khomeini(ar) considered this hadith as authentic? QUOTE Truly the scholars are the ...

I read the book on Fadak from Sayyed Baqir Sadr. When explaining the verse 19:5-6, he writes : QUOTE The inheritance in the verse means the inheritance of wealth because it is wealth, which actually transfers from the bequeather to the heir but knowledge and prophethood do not transfer in the real sense. http://www.maaref-foundation.com/english/l..._hist ory/05.htm And then I ...

the hadith about the prophet not leaving inheritence is weak and rejected brother ,even though we have this hadith in our books of hadith , it's a hadith narrated by sunni narrators secondly this hadith contradicts the koran

When there is dispute regarding two opposing ahadith, refer to Quran.

QUOTE (bakr_umar @ May 10 2008, 08:26 PM) I read the book on Fadak from Sayyed Baqir Sadr. When explaining the verse 19:5-6, he writes : http://www.maaref-foundation.com/english/l..._hist ory/05.htm And then I read this hadith : http://www.al-shia.com/html/eng/books/hadi...2/par t2-ch4.htm And this one : Can somebody help me to understand the matter ? Very good ...

QUOTE (bakr_umar @ May 10 2008, 09:26 AM) I read the book on Fadak from Sayyed Baqir Sadr. When explaining the verse 19:5-6, he writes : http://www.maaref-foundation.com/english/l..._hist ory/05.htm And then I read this hadith : http://www.al-shia.com/html/eng/books/hadi...2/par t2-ch4.htm And this one : Can somebody help me to understand the matter ? I may be ...

Salaams Bakr Umar you claim you are shia but all i ever see you do is copty and paste from sites like Ansar.Org! Anyway this hadith has been comprehensively explained in AA's article on Fadak

QUOTE (Aghamalang @ May 10 2008, 02:32 PM) Salaams Bakr Umar you claim you are shia but all i ever see you do is copty and paste from sites like Ansar.Org! Anyway this hadith has been comprehensively explained in AA's article on Fadak So what if I am a shia ? I have to close my eyes ? Seriously you think we are in 8 century ? 10 century ? or 15 century ?...

QUOTE (bakr_umar @ May 11 2008, 12:49 AM) So what if I am a shia ? I have to close my eyes ? Seriously you think we are in 8 century ? 10 century ? or 15 century ? There is a difference between a seeker of truth and a deciever , I for one do critisize things in the Sunni and the Shi'i sect in order to search for the truth , but where have you said anything in the defense of Shi...

QUOTE (bakr_umar @ May 11 2008, 07:19 AM) So what if I am a shia ? I have to close my eyes ? Seriously you think we are in 8 century ? 10 century ? or 15 century ? Whether we live in any century, compare any hadith with Quran for its authenticity. This is what Shia hadith writes say about valuing a hadith.