Did Fatima Ra Do Mutah? | Thread profile

Why would they do mutah when there was the option for a permanent marriage?

QUOTE (Akbar007 @ Jul 12 2008, 06:04 PM) Why would they do mutah when there was the option for a permanent marriage? Salaamunulaykum wr wb. Virtually all singles have the option for permanent marriages.

QUOTE (gogiison2 @ Jul 13 2008, 04:37 AM) Salaamunulaykum wr wb. Virtually all singles have the option for permanent marriages. What about the singles that do not come under the category of "Virtually" ? (like young people who cannot afford a permanent marriage)

QUOTE (Akbar007 @ Jul 12 2008, 06:10 PM) What about the singles that do not come under the category of "Virtually" ? (like young people who cannot afford a permanent marriage) Permanent marriage doesn't need to be expensive. I said virtually for any odd reasons that may be. Maybe for the 0.0000001 people living today. For example if a believer lived in a country of all ...

QUOTE (gogiison2 @ Jul 13 2008, 03:51 AM) Permanent marriage doesn't need to be expensive. If only everyone shared this view of yours. QUOTE I said virtually for any odd reasons that may be. For example if a believer lived in a country of all atheists and had no money to leave that country in order to marry one whom may be deemed permissible. So you admit mutah is...

QUOTE (toyibonline @ Jul 12 2008, 06:28 PM) Are you saying the Holy Prophet introduced an unnecessary Sunnah? Never will I say that inshaAllah. Please read 4:24.

QUOTE (farris @ Jul 12 2008, 04:49 PM) ive got a single question and a simple answer is required please? did fatima ra do muta? did khadija ra do muta? did any female ahlel bayt do muta? did the wives of the prophet pbuh do mutah? Lets not make use of emotional propaganda in our discussion of whether mutah is halal in Islam or not. While historical records suggest that ...

QUOTE (Akbar007 @ Jul 12 2008, 06:27 PM) If only everyone shared this view of yours. So you admit mutah is necessary in certain situations... so whats the argument here? Life isn't all about sexual relations. Mutah without copulation may be the best answer for many. With an intention of charity, I think one cannot go wrong. This post has been edited by gogiison2 :...

There are lot things halal, but do we get to practice all? Haj is very important, do all the muslims get to do it? Let me quote from Answering Ansar that will satisfy you hopefully Zurarah narrated: Abdullah ibn Umair Al-Laithi came to Abu Jafar [as] and he asked him: "What do you say about the Mutah of women?" He answered: "Allah made it halal in His book, and on the tongue of ...

QUOTE (gogiison2 @ Jul 13 2008, 04:05 AM) Life isn't all about sexual relations. Yes, life isin't all about that. Thats the reason why mutah is allowed as a last resort, to avoid falling into sin. QUOTE Mutah without copulation may be the best answer for many. Maybe. Maybe not. QUOTE With an intention of charity, I think one cannot go wrong. What do ...