Cursing Ayesha........ Isit Right? | Thread profile

QUOTE(Yousif @ Oct 12 2006, 10:47 PM) once again you got a source for ? hm.. just a suggestion why dont you curse her in private , Imam Ali didnt curse any one , due to the fact that it wasnt right at that time as it would be very harmful in those circumstances dont you see the same situation now? dont give me other scenarios , if his sons cursed them , why didnt he ? either he ...

Its wrong to curse her.

QUOTE(tauq786xxx @ Oct 11 2006, 05:59 PM) BROO THROUGH AS MANY LAANATS AS U WANT ON HER... FACT OF THE MATTER IS... NO MATTER HOW MUCH WE HATE HER N WISHH HER A HUNDRED ETERNITYS OF PUNISHMNT... WE DONT HAVE ANY RIGHT TO SAY ANYTHING TO HER... IF MY MAULA DIDNT SAY ANYTHING TO HER... HU R U OR I TO SAY NEFIN AGENST HER... ALSO IN ISLAM WE SHUDNT JUDGE ANY1 ELSE WE SHUD JUST ...

[quote] how could you draw such a conclusion it goes against Quran ( surah tahreem) ayesha defied the Quran and the orders of Rasulallah(saw) so it was legitimate to fight her and that is why she is a hateful personality, she is responsible for the death of thousands of muslims[/quote] no surah munafiqoon exhonerated her and dclared those that accused her of munafiqs and those that still ...

halo , dont wouldnt u look up to be like Imam Ali which u cant but its an inspiration now again , source for ur quote unless you dont have one which you dont and also if Imam Ali did not curse , Neither did the Prophet what gives you the permission ? now now dont tell me try to do half the things they did, we allready do most of the things they told us to do , and taught us , but ...

exactly bro yousif. its people like bro halo who give the shia a negative perception amongst sunnis.bro halo stop cursing those that the prophet loved and even other sensible shia agree ali didnt curse any sahabah so why do you curse the sahabah when ali didnt?? and you pretend to follow ali . but then you are not shia after all . YOU ARE A SUNNI WINDING EVERYONE UP HERE.

WoW. Dont people have better things than discussing cursing the prophet's wife? If Ali released her after her revolt and let her go, so we all should let her issue go. In these days of the remembrance of the shahadat of Imam Ali ,we should instead be giving alms like he did, spreading justice like he did, supporting the rights of the weak like he did, feeding the hungry like he did, taking ...

QUOTE(umar_khan @ Oct 13 2006, 10:39 AM) exactly bro yousif. its people like bro halo who give the shia a negative perception amongst sunnis.bro halo stop cursing those that the prophet loved and even other sensible shia agree ali didnt curse any sahabah so why do you curse the sahabah when ali didnt?? and you pretend to follow ali . but then you are not shia after all . ...

QUOTE(Faqir_e_Hussaini @ Oct 13 2006, 11:23 AM) Buddy, Tabarra is the part of our religion and it is in Faroh e Din (besides Namaz, Roza etc) it is wajib on every shia to love those who love Muhammad & Aley Muhammad (i.e Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Hussain a.s.) and curse/dislike Alay Muhammad enemies In Dua e Nudba it is very clearly mention that Of Whomsoever I am the Mawlaa (Lord, ...

Okay wait. Tabarrah is part of our faith, you are correct. But what is Tabarrah? In Shi'i fiqh we have to go to through legitimate sources. 1. The Qur'an, 2. the Hadith and Sunnah, and 3. the legitimate representatives of our Imam Mahdi . Is Tabarrah as the Qur'an says, "renouncing" those that are against Allah and the Ahlul Bayt ? Is Tabarrah as the Imams have shown the ...