Abd Allah Ibn Masud. Opinion Of Shias Scholars ? | Thread profile

salam, I read somewhere that Abd Allah ibn Masud was a famous scholar of Kufa under which many Sahabas have learn before Imam Ali came to Kufa and estabished his own School. 1-I want to know whta's the opinion of Shias Scholars on Abd Allah ibn Masud ? Is he reliable and do we have hadith from him in our Shias books ? 2-Who was his teacher ? Because we know that Imam Ali's teacher was...

QUOTE (Dar'ul_Islam @ Jul 14 2008, 03:32 PM) Just an interesting observations, but if you are Shi'a, why do you post things that are targeted to your fellow brothers of the Shia in the Shia Sunni Dialogue forum. Why would a shi'a ask opinions of Shi'as in such a forum...? thats some good observation

QUOTE (Dar'ul_Islam @ Jul 14 2008, 02:32 PM) Just an interesting observations, but if you are Shi'a, why do you post things that are targeted to your fellow brothers of the Shia in the Shia Sunni Dialogue forum. Why would a shi'a ask opinions of Shi'as in such a forum...? I understand your question. As you know I am an ex-sunni, so some informations about Ahul Sunna Wal Jama'a...

QUOTE (bakr_umar @ Jul 14 2008, 04:23 PM) I understand your question. As you know I am an ex-sunni, so some informations about Ahul Sunna Wal Jama'a I get them very late. In fact, I want to understand why Sunni and Shia are in conflict on the question of Sahaba, as we Shias critsize all time the Sahabas of the Prophet, maybe it's the picture given by Sunni Brothers. Yeah we "...

Anyone who is not a Shia is not reliable. I think its enough to write about this

QUOTE (shahg @ Jul 14 2008, 03:32 PM) Anyone who is not a Shia is not reliable. I think its enough to write about this lol Then Abu Hanifah is also a SHIA, because according to some people he was deemed to be a SHIA maybe not a RAFIZI. Ok brothers, If you don't have any interesting awsers to give then don't waste your time infalse accusation like SHIASOLDIER or like SHAHG ...

QUOTE (P. Ease @ Jul 14 2008, 03:57 PM) As an ex salafi, I'm having problems with this clan mentality of ''us'' and ''them''. If someone claims to be an exsunni and a shi'i, what would you expect from such a person but cricital questions? I mean, give the guy a break. I'm actually learning a lot from his questions. The Prophet and Ali were being laughed at or ridiculed, ...

Sayyid al-Khoei has an interesting discussion on him in his Mu`jam ar-Rijal, discussing different reports on him: http://u-of-islam.net/uofislam/maktaba/Rij...jam/1 1/a344.htm He begins by a report from Kashi in his book of rijal which says that al-Fadhl b. Shadhan (ar) (a companion of Imam Ridha and an important scholar amongst the Shi'a) was asked about Ibn Mas'ud and Hudhayfa. He ...

I came across a tradition in Amaali Al-Sheikh Al-Mufeed where Abdullah ibn Masood is regarded by Hazrat Ali as sharing a similar quality with Salmaan and Miqdad . From history, Abudllah ibn Masood was Chief Judge in the city of Kufah and became the target of jealousy of Waleed, a vile man, the governor of Kufah and half-brother of Uthman. Waleed conspired alongwith Marwaan, the ...

for the record, a question should be a question no matter who is asking it, and we, as shia, should be able to respond without attacking the possible affiliations of the person asking it. If the members of this forum continually call someone a wahabi, or sunni, or whatever anytime they ask a question (and you have no real way of knowing they're not asking a genuine question), then are you ...