Bigfooty's dumbest trade suggestions (Port Adelaide edition) | Thread profile

Fair enough thread, but what about the multitude of (fellow) Port supporters who have continuously put Thurstans name forward as a way for us to get a first or second round pick, or as part of a deal to get a quality youngster to the club.

So who did that then?

Quote: Originally Posted by Port_GW Fair enough thread, but what about the multitude of (fellow) Port supporters who have continuously put Thurstans name forward as a way for us to get a first or second round pick, or as part of a deal to get a quality youngster to the club. What are you saying GW - that Toby is worthless? I agree he is not worth anything below pick 50, but he is a more ...

Add them as you see them, there'll be plenty more. From the thread "Salopek, Surjan and Symes Quote: Originally Posted by murphster We should try and get one of these for Jordan Russell, they are all young players and would be a fair swap IMO, Salopek would be the best as he is a Victorian.

Some really high functioning posters in that thread!

i had to laugh when one of them posted that ports list is middle of the road, aging, and on a serious decline for the next 5 years just makes you wonder if they have seen any port games at all

Or the statement that Carlton didn't rate Salopek and the only reason he re-signed with us was that Pagan didn't rate him worthy of a PSD pick. Quote: Originally Posted by cypher The goss says we could have had him in the PSD last year but Pagan didn't rate him, so are you sure? . . . Quote: Originally Posted by cypher Or he re-signed after Pagan didn't show any interest and Carlton ...

There's some good ones in here, eg ... Quote: Ok, how about this: Jordan Russell, Trent Sporn and Bret Thornton for Pick 5 and Chaplin or Quote: What do you guys think of this trade?? Jordan Russell, Trent Sporn, Adrian Deluca and Troy Longmuir to Port Adelaide for Pick 5 and Troy Chaplin. Funny how prominently Carlton feature ...

The strangest thing is that all three played well against them this year at Telstra Dome.... R10, 2006: Carlton v Port Obviously not many of the supporters turned up that day!

Quote: Originally Posted by Malibu#27 Or the statement that Carlton didn't rate Salopek and the only reason he re-signed with us was that Pagan didn't rate him worthy of a PSD pick. You've misinterpreted the post. Pagan wanted an experienced ruckman to back up French ahead of a young player like Salopek who hasn't had a stand out season until this year. Salopek was a bit like Russell at this ...