Cursing Aysha | Thread profile

QUOTE (iraqi_shia @ Apr 18 2008, 07:47 PM) stick to the teaching of the ahl bayt AS. Dont try and interpret things yourself and make rulings. If this action was beneficial, we would see our scholars doing it, but we dont. We make taqleed to our scholars because they have educated themselves to a high degree so they can know what is right and what is wrong. You come in and think ...

your views on sending lanat to ayesha Reason for edit: Reworded Title

permissable? are you insane? its waajib

i believe so 2 just curious what our irani nd iraqi brothers havee 2 say

hmmm lets see, she 1) brought an army against Ali 2) Would not let Imam Hassan be buried next to his grandfathor 3) Talked behind Rasool's back with his other wives (you all know about the honey drink incident) 4) she is the daughter of Abu Bakr (this should be enough)

Sayed Fadhlallah(ha) says : "Some people curse some of the Messenger's wives who might have committed some mistakes, but this does not mean that we should curse them, for we should, as one of our old scholar, Sayyed Mohammed Baqir Hujatulislam, says , treat them well, in honour of the one they are linked to." Friday Sermon- 04/05/2007 w/s This post has been edited by Jondab...

bro u follow sayyed fadhlallah. ill follow the prophet who said "i am at war with whoever is at war with ali"

maula da malang.. i told u these iranians/iraqis have different thoughts on this matter

Its not permissable to curse them Since it causes disunity and we will let Allah decide what happens to them This post has been edited by Rubaiyat : Apr 16 2008, 02:11 PM

QUOTE (Rubaiyat @ Apr 16 2008, 07:10 PM) Its not permissable to curse them Since it causes disunity and we will let Allah decide what happens to them mashallah ur mindset has become clear. stick to refraining from tabarra if you want, to please those who hate the ahlebayt. cos unity with them IS so important im not replying more. khudhahafiz