Posts Topics Forums Images
Search videos from message boards Videos Search messages from microblogs Microblogs Search messages from imdb.com Imdb Search messages from yuku.com Yuku Search messages from lefora.com (free forums) Lefora
My account: Login | Sign Up
Loading... 

Critiques | Forum profile

Forum profile page for Critiques on http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk. This report page is the aggregated overview from a single forum: Critiques, located on the Message Board at http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk. This forum profile page summarizes the general forum statistics such as: Users Activity, Forum Activity, and Top Authors, which are reported in either a table or graph below for a given reporting time period. Additional forum profile information for "Critiques" on the Message Board at http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk is also shown in the following ways:

1) Latest Active Threads
2) Hot Threads for Last Week

Warning: These statistics are generated using 'best efforts' and can experience delays and reporting errors at times. Please note that such statistics do not constitute a forum's popularity and/or exact posting volumes at any given reporting period.

Site: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles - Critiques (site profile, domain info sffchronicles.co.uk)
Title: Critiques
Url: http://www.sffchronicles.co.uk/forum/critiques/
Users activity: 4 posts per thread
Forum activity: 51 active thread during last week
 

Posting activity on Critiques:

  Week Month 3 Months
Threads: 51 124 313
Post: 163 485 1,261
 

Critiques Posting activity graph:

Posts by:  day  week  month 

Top authors during last week:

Name
Posts
fkatona
26
user's latest post:
The Road Through Kavalia,...
Published (2009-12-04 03:07:00)
So I'm in rework #3. Scrapped the whole darn thing and started over. Changed to first person. Changed the characters. I decided starting in the real world would help create a nice framework. And , I have a working title. Ta da! This is very stylized, so I hope it works. __________________________________________________ ___ I left school early the day I returned to Kavalia. Normally I rode the bus, even though I was old enough to drive....
Vargev
15
user's latest post:
First few pages of E.D.F...
Published (2009-12-05 23:41:00)
Thanks chris. Thank you for your input Theresa, however i never actually depend on anybody to fix my mistakes, i always endeavour to find and fix whatever mistakes i make myself. As for my manuscripts, i always write the entire novel out in note form first, then type the whole thing up again on computer, reviewing and checking as i go, then i re-read and check all over again. and only when i am absolutely satisfied that i cannot get it...
blacknorth
10
user's latest post:
Beg. of a short story
Published (2009-12-05 14:17:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by tigerlily14 ...and any chance I could get an example of passive-action? because I probably do that a lot w/ out even knowing Here's a few links - There's a little exercise you can do here (subvert the business purpose of the site with a little fantasy ): Passive and Active Voice Starting a sentence with an -ing phrase | Deanna Hoak The Parts of Speech And there's lots of info if you google. I have...
Prototype
9
user's latest post:
Edge of the World
Published (2009-11-29 16:57:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by fkatona I'm glad my suggestions were helpful! Trying to find a logic behind the new name for the Force will help you get to that perfect name. The best part is, once you find it, you don't have to reveal how you got there at all! Maybe one or two really saavy people will connect the dots, but everyone else will accept the name for what it is. The process is just for you, not for the reader or even for the...
Belador
9
user's latest post:
Happy New Years
Published (2009-12-01 22:05:00)
Hi, Just a quick comment - I really liked this - I think if it was tightened up a little more it would be cracking. Personally, perhaps it would be good to have a little more chat between the old woman and the man; perhaps she asks him why he's on the train on NYE, and he talks a little about his private life, just to bring him to life a little more and to help explain where the 26 minutes to midnight went a little better. And I'm...
dreamhunter
8
user's latest post:
Reclaiming Eden
Published (2009-12-05 16:58:00)
Blimey! Oh dear! Sorry mate. Somehow your story's title made me think you were W-Three. Cos it's got 'Eden' in it as well. LOL.
Culhwch
7
user's latest post:
The Road Through Kavalia,...
Published (2009-12-04 04:51:00)
There's nothing technically wrong with this, but for some reason I feel disconnected from it. I can't put my finger on it, though. I have a thought that the paragraphs don't flow well into each other, and that may be it. They seem to exist in their own little bubbles. It might just be me though... There's some good writing here. I loved the line, '...because people in nineteen thirty something smacked each other to...
Nik
7
user's latest post:
Part of prologue
Published (2009-12-04 01:15:00)
I... I don't know where to begin. It is a draft, so I won't quibble about the punctuation. Unfortunately, that just adds to the surreality. A wizard war ended by an 'ultimate weapon (TM)' ? A later woman who hitches a ride with a slaver, then 'undoes' the town ? There's too much of a time-line jump to do more than bewilder... Lovely language, lovely settings, but...
chrispenycate
7
user's latest post:
First few pages of E.D.F...
Published (2009-12-05 23:09:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Vargev For those who were looking for the hook, i've decided to post a little bit more, mainly because i hadn't typed that part up yet from my notes. “Well Lieutenant I am going to retire, I have an important briefing with Admiral Mc’Kenzie in the morning.” Michael said suppressing a sigh. “Okay, I’ll see you tomorrow Captain.” And with that Kinraid watched the remainder of the outer colony news,...
ctg
6
user's latest post:
Mistake - Beginning
Published (2009-12-03 17:25:00)
It's just a draft.
 

Latest active threads on Critiques::

Started 1 week ago (2009-11-30 04:01:00)  by Vargev
First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. This book is a direct continuation of E.D.F chronicles 1 - the Krenaran massacre, albeit 8 months on. If anyone needs a little clarification a full synopsis of the first book can be found here. E.D.F chronicles - synopsis E.D.F Chronicles book 2 : E.D.F Resurgent By Ian Smethurst...
Thread:  Show this thread (26 posts)   Thread info: First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. Size: 7,892 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 month ago (2009-11-05 04:12:00)  by reiver33
Out Of The Dark I've obviously been watching too many old films recently... One It was one of those background conversations that, for some reason, stand out against the general hubbub and attract your attention. One of those conversations that mean trouble; headed your way, and fast. “Busted Flush, Busted Flush, this is Antarctica Traffic Control. Are...
Thread:  Show this thread (28 posts)   Thread info: Out Of The Dark Size: 13 kb
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Out Of The Dark :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 6 days, 16 hours ago (2009-11-30 14:30:00)  by ctg
I think there's multitude of errors that doesn't play in your or your story favour. The reason is that your pacing goes into the action mode without you giving us a clear detail of what is really going on. What I would love to see is you to rewrite this whole thing. Forget the little details like the names on the guns etcetera, and let the reader to image what's going in those burning wrecks, ...
Thread:  Show this thread (11 posts)   Thread info: Reclaiming Eden Size: 1,071 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Reclaiming Eden :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 4 days, 18 hours ago (2009-12-02 11:41:00)  by LukeW
Hey TL14 A few things stuck me as I was looking over your piece. 1. I thought there was too much description. I know you are trying to set the scene but, for me, it was getting a little bit dull. You’ve just taken over 500 words to say: ‘Two adventurers walked into a potion shop and an elf-lady said “hi”.’ That’s obviously the (extremely) shortened version but hopefully there is ...
Thread:  Show this thread (8 posts)   Thread info: Beg. of a short story Size: 3,944 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Beg. of a short story :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 3 days, 3 hours ago (2009-12-04 03:07:00)  by fkatona
The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 So I'm in rework #3. Scrapped the whole darn thing and started over. Changed to first person. Changed the characters. I decided starting in the real world would help create a nice framework. And , I have a working title. Ta da! This is very stylized, so I hope it works. _________________________________________________ _ ___ I ...
Thread:  Show this thread (6 posts)   Thread info: The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 Size: 4,332 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 4 days, 7 hours ago (2009-12-02 22:58:00)  by LukeW
Quote: Originally Posted by arpa It was not a happy day for Alina. The happy days had been short in coming for a long time since Honored Bethiman had accepted the master’s hospitality. For everybody. Honored Bethiman was not happy man. It was hard to believe that he ever smiled even in his childhood. Well it was harder still to imagine that he was ever a child. ...
Thread:  Show this thread (7 posts)   Thread info: Got a moment? Size: 3,273 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Got a moment? :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 3 days, 5 hours ago (2009-12-04 00:49:00)  by anthorn
Part of prologue Hi. Long time no post, here's a sample from my prologue, I've posted a bit before but I've added stuff to it. And the second bit is new and I'm unsure of it. All comments welcome. Long post. You are warned PROLOGUE. The left path is death, the right path is life But the middle path that fine line between Is the hardest path to walk and the journey...
Thread:  Show this thread (4 posts)   Thread info: Part of prologue Size: 12 kb
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Part of prologue :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 week, 4 days ago (2009-11-25 18:08:00)  by Glitch
I think it has a hook quality. It sounds like the beginning of a banking crisis.
Thread:  Show this thread (16 posts)   Thread info: Mistake - Beginning Size: 144 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Mistake - Beginning :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 6 days, 20 hours ago (2009-11-30 10:20:00)  by The Judge
Hello there and Welcome to the Chronicles. If you haven't done so already, pop across to the introductins forum and tell us a little about yourself and be welcomed officially. First of all, you deserve credit for having the courage to put something up here for public evisceration, though I have to say it is, for me, a trifle long for a critique-request from a newbie. I understand why you ...
Thread:  Show this thread (8 posts)   Thread info: Eden - A short story Size: 3,519 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Eden - A short story :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 week, 4 days ago (2009-11-25 11:00:00)  by Boneman
Hi Bela, welcome to the chrons, hope you enjoy a long and fruitful association with us. Nice opening, certainly a good hook, and had me wanting to know more. It's a very earthy tone, I'm assuming the choice of the word 'rut' is deliberate, because it certainly caught my attention, in that it's not one that you generally associate with humans, and at the end I wondered if she was human, ...
Thread:  Show this thread (30 posts)   Thread info: First 500 words of 'Artisan' Size: 1,840 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: First 500 words of 'Artisan' :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
 

Hot threads for last week on Critiques::

Started 1 week ago (2009-11-30 04:01:00)  by Vargev
First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. This book is a direct continuation of E.D.F chronicles 1 - the Krenaran massacre, albeit 8 months on. If anyone needs a little clarification a full synopsis of the first book can be found here. E.D.F chronicles - synopsis E.D.F Chronicles book 2 : E.D.F Resurgent By Ian Smethurst...
Thread:  Show this thread (26 posts)   Thread info: First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. Size: 7,892 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "First few pages of E.D.F Chronicles book 2 - E.D.F resurgent. :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 week, 4 days ago (2009-11-25 11:00:00)  by Boneman
Hi Bela, welcome to the chrons, hope you enjoy a long and fruitful association with us. Nice opening, certainly a good hook, and had me wanting to know more. It's a very earthy tone, I'm assuming the choice of the word 'rut' is deliberate, because it certainly caught my attention, in that it's not one that you generally associate with humans, and at the end I wondered if she was human, ...
Thread:  Show this thread (30 posts)   Thread info: First 500 words of 'Artisan' Size: 1,840 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: First 500 words of 'Artisan' :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Re: Reclaiming Eden - 11 new posts
Started 6 days, 16 hours ago (2009-11-30 14:30:00)  by ctg
I think there's multitude of errors that doesn't play in your or your story favour. The reason is that your pacing goes into the action mode without you giving us a clear detail of what is really going on. What I would love to see is you to rewrite this whole thing. Forget the little details like the names on the guns etcetera, and let the reader to image what's going in those burning wrecks, ...
Thread:  Show this thread (11 posts)   Thread info: Reclaiming Eden Size: 1,071 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Reclaiming Eden :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 week, 6 days ago (2009-11-23 09:35:00)  by MattyK
Quote: Originally Posted by Lioness After Eron had left, Grace walked into the music rooms, lost. Everything here reminded her of him. There was the piano he had lovingly played so many years ago. And the harp. His favoured instrument. She Quote: ran a hand gently over its smooth wood and taut strings, and tensed as she imagined him ...
Thread:  Show this thread (31 post)   Thread info: Music Rooms - another NaNoWriMo excerpt Size: 4,870 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Music Rooms - another NaNoWriMo excerpt :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 1 week, 4 days ago (2009-11-25 18:08:00)  by Glitch
I think it has a hook quality. It sounds like the beginning of a banking crisis.
Thread:  Show this thread (16 posts)   Thread info: Mistake - Beginning Size: 144 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Mistake - Beginning :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 6 days, 20 hours ago (2009-11-30 10:20:00)  by The Judge
Hello there and Welcome to the Chronicles. If you haven't done so already, pop across to the introductins forum and tell us a little about yourself and be welcomed officially. First of all, you deserve credit for having the courage to put something up here for public evisceration, though I have to say it is, for me, a trifle long for a critique-request from a newbie. I understand why you ...
Thread:  Show this thread (8 posts)   Thread info: Eden - A short story Size: 3,519 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Eden - A short story :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 4 days, 18 hours ago (2009-12-02 11:41:00)  by LukeW
Hey TL14 A few things stuck me as I was looking over your piece. 1. I thought there was too much description. I know you are trying to set the scene but, for me, it was getting a little bit dull. You’ve just taken over 500 words to say: ‘Two adventurers walked into a potion shop and an elf-lady said “hi”.’ That’s obviously the (extremely) shortened version but hopefully there is ...
Thread:  Show this thread (8 posts)   Thread info: Beg. of a short story Size: 3,944 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Beg. of a short story :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Re: Got a moment? - 7 new posts
Started 4 days, 7 hours ago (2009-12-02 22:58:00)  by LukeW
Quote: Originally Posted by arpa It was not a happy day for Alina. The happy days had been short in coming for a long time since Honored Bethiman had accepted the master’s hospitality. For everybody. Honored Bethiman was not happy man. It was hard to believe that he ever smiled even in his childhood. Well it was harder still to imagine that he was ever a child. ...
Thread:  Show this thread (7 posts)   Thread info: Got a moment? Size: 3,273 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Got a moment? :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 6 days, 15 hours ago (2009-11-30 15:02:00)  by ctg
Quote: Originally Posted by Glisterspeck Eggs, thought Unkel. Eggs wizard wants. Let wizard find eggs if wizard wants eggs. Not Unkel's job. Unkel is lantern keeper. Unkel's begetter, lantern keeper. His begetter's begetter, lantern keeper. Since the fall of Gernreg we are lantern keepers. Let wizard find eggs if wizard wants eggs. Use italics to ...
Thread:  Show this thread (6 posts)   Thread info: Looking for readers: sample chapter Size: 5,710 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "Re: Looking for readers: sample chapter :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"
Started 3 days, 3 hours ago (2009-12-04 03:07:00)  by fkatona
The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 So I'm in rework #3. Scrapped the whole darn thing and started over. Changed to first person. Changed the characters. I decided starting in the real world would help create a nice framework. And , I have a working title. Ta da! This is very stylized, so I hope it works. _________________________________________________ _ ___ I ...
Thread:  Show this thread (6 posts)   Thread info: The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 Size: 4,332 bytes
Related Threads: Same Site | All Sites
Customize:  Customize "The Road Through Kavalia, beginning of Ch 1 :: Critiques :: Science Fiction Fantasy Chronicles"