|
More site info...
Speculation | Forum profile
|
|
Forum profile page for Speculation on http://forums.mtgsalvation.com.
This report page is the aggregated overview from a single forum: Speculation, located on the Message Board at http://forums.mtgsalvation.com.
This forum profile page summarizes the general forum statistics such as: Users Activity, Forum Activity, and Top Authors, which are reported in either a table or graph below for a given reporting time period.
Additional forum profile information for "Speculation" on the Message Board at http://forums.mtgsalvation.com is also shown in the following ways:
1) Latest Active Threads
2) Hot Threads for Last Week
Warning: These statistics are generated using 'best efforts' and can experience delays and reporting errors at times. Please note that such statistics do not constitute a forum's popularity and/or exact posting volumes at any given reporting period.
|
|
|
|
|
Posting activity on Speculation:
|
|
Week
|
Month
|
3 Months
|
|
Threads:
|
105
|
355
|
1,430
|
|
Post:
|
1,141
|
3,841
|
15,614
|
|
|
Speculation Posting activity graph:
|
Top authors during last week:
user's latest post:
Bad Moon/Mutilate reprint?
Published (2009-11-07 23:52:00)
Bad Moon has a 0% chance of being reprinted. It got its chance to return to Standard in Time Spiral's Timeshifted block, specifically because it's incredibly out of color. Mutilate is a card that could come back, but I'm not sure there's much to discuss since the answer is "it could come back, but there's no specific reason to think it will in the near future."
user's latest post:
Hint at Worldwake mechanic...
Published (2009-11-08 02:35:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by TK-421 I thought I'd just post the rules text of Kicker just to help with the thought processes. Now you can look at the quote and take out any word you like to see if it makes sense as Kicker without... Yes, I know it's very literal, but hopefully it'll make some inspiration. Hopefully it helps! You - While multiplayer-friendly, it seems like a pointless growth (why is my opponent choosing to help...
user's latest post:
goyf? - Page 3 - MTG Salvation...
Published (2009-11-08 03:19:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Ardan Another thing to stop the goyf being re-printed theories, I'm pretty sure that goyf's like kavu's are pretty unique to Dominaria, not saying they might not appear anywhere else in the multiverse but so they have be unique to that plain. This might mean that the next time goyf could be printed is the next time we return to Dominaria, which will probably only happen in 5 years time - if ever....
user's latest post:
Full art judge foil alpha/beta...
Published (2009-11-08 17:22:00)
The Reserve List only exists for products that are sold. They can reprint anything on it and give it away for free as a prize or a promo without care. __________________ My Magic Blog: http://necropotence.wordpress.com
user's latest post:
Dark Ritual, Cabal Ritual, ... -...
Published (2009-11-05 01:08:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Joyd There seems to be a trend in general of avoiding mana acceleration outside of green. There's not even (to my best memory) a two-mana artifact that accelerates you in standard. (A few years ago, there were like thirteen or something.) Yep, the last one I can remember is mind stone . It seems to me that the trend is deliberate. I like that acceleration (at least early acceleration) is pretty much exclusive...
user's latest post:
goyf? - Page 2 - MTG Salvation...
Published (2009-11-07 04:44:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Surging Chaos It's not surprising that when you make a last minute change(s) to a card and fail to properly playtest it, disaster will usually result. Actually I have a feeling that most times they make last minute changes like this, nothing bad or unexpected happens. If it resulted in disaster 9 times out of 10, they'd stopping doing it, but if bad stuff happens 1 out of every 500 changes, then...
user's latest post:
Dark Ritual, Cabal Ritual, ... -...
Published (2009-11-05 10:17:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by Dr_Discomfort I think I've got it Jerk Ritual instant Target opponent chooses one - add to your mana pool or deal 5(4?) damage to a player targeted by Jerk Ritual. I probably worded that badly but you get the idea. I wanted it to be divisible among the opponent and their creatures but I can't figure out how to write that out in a way that isn't convoluted and still targets. I made it have to hit the...
user's latest post:
goyf? - Page 3 - MTG Salvation...
Published (2009-11-08 02:51:00)
Tarmogoyf was (is) broken. Just attacking and blocking are more than enough when you're attacking and blocking with a 2 mana 3/4 or 4/5.
user's latest post:
GreenIcon--ReadLinkBeforeVoting...
Published (2009-11-05 10:49:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by charlequin I think this is true, but they really would need to have a solid plan about how to eliminate the "lame" factor from treefolk. I think the fact that they're a green creature that nonetheless focuses on toughness over power really puts them at a disadvantage right to start. Treefolk focusing on toughness was really only their mechanic in Lorwyn block and only because typically in the...
user's latest post:
Will they ever reprint...
Published (2009-11-08 16:06:00)
Quote: Originally Posted by flaming infinity No, that was Blinding Angel . Serra Angel hasn't seen much competitive play since the very early days of UW control. Whatever, the point remains the same.
|
|
|
|
Latest active threads on Speculation::
Started 1 day, 15 hours ago (2009-11-09 08:53:00)
by archie-d
corrupt only just rotated, i guess it could be in M11, but with tendrils and consume spirit around already, not sure i see the point.
edit: i, love, comma's, .
Started 8 months, 2 weeks ago (2009-02-23 02:59:00)
by Metallix87
The most likely candidate right now is Splice.
Started 1 week ago (2009-11-03 22:12:00)
by Metallix87
Maybe a functional reprint, but Kavu are long-gone.
Started 1 day, 15 hours ago (2009-11-09 08:55:00)
by jethier
It doesn't really spill the beans, unless he somehow said it's a set of enemy-color rare non-basics, or even a new set of allied-color rare non-basics - that would be something. The former would be interesting, the latter would piss me off.
I really enjoy his art though - here's hoping they do all the basics as full art just like Zen.
Started 1 week, 3 days ago (2009-10-31 05:17:00)
by JinxedIdol
Quote:
Originally Posted by frankcseke
As this is pure speculation, the current black cards being promoted begs the question as to whether M11 or the current block will reprint Dark Ritual (not very likely), Cabal Ritual (more likely than DR), or some new version thereof.
Did I miss anything? Which specific ...
Started 2 days, 8 hours ago (2009-11-08 15:43:00)
by rogerkun
Full art judge foil alpha/beta duals?
With the new full art frame for land cards, do you think it's possible that they would release full art judge foil duals? They would look amazing and be very popular. I know wizards would probably never do it, but, I don't know, just think it would be cool.
Spoiler:...
Started 3 days ago (2009-11-07 23:19:00)
by Barinellos
Duress didn't actually get new art for DvD, but instead got new art for M10 that ended up being put into DvD.
I want to say it was mentioned in one of the arcanas and that is why the Demonic side had one extra alt art rather than divine. (Or at least I think it did, not sure 100%)
Started 2 days, 1 hour ago (2009-11-08 22:40:00)
by Sniffnoy
This is just a slight variant of Utopia Vow . It would definitely be an enchantment. It has no interaction with Landfall; no lands are entering the battlefield.
Started 2 weeks ago (2009-10-27 13:37:00)
by SKRules
Your idea is interesting except that he says it's shown up in another design. What design would that have shown up on?
I agree that they'll probably do it in New Mirrodin though.
Started 6 days, 23 hours ago (2009-11-04 00:10:00)
by viperesque
Or he could just have been using a perfectly ordinary English idiom without
any subtext whatsoever. But Allies with kicker sound fun, as long as the
kicker grants an extra bonus to Allies.
|
|
Hot threads for last week on Speculation::
Started 1 week, 3 days ago (2009-10-31 08:11:00)
by Vodalian Javelineer
I voted for Chimera. I love the idea of huge green critters that are amalgams of the best parts other powerful creatures. They would have the benefits of all, and probably be super-sized as well.
Primordials is a good choice too, but seems more generic.
Started 8 months, 2 weeks ago (2009-02-23 02:59:00)
by Metallix87
The most likely candidate right now is Splice.
Started 1 week, 3 days ago (2009-10-31 16:29:00)
by fearmeordie
You posted this on the source, and I didn't like it there, either. You
could've at least had the list hidden in a spoiler or something. Right now
it's an abomination.
Started 5 days ago (2009-11-05 23:49:00)
by YoshiOfADown
They have stated time and time again that Goyf was a mistake. It's not
coming back.
Started 1 week ago (2009-11-03 22:12:00)
by Metallix87
Maybe a functional reprint, but Kavu are long-gone.
Started 1 week, 3 days ago (2009-10-31 05:17:00)
by JinxedIdol
Quote:
Originally Posted by frankcseke
As this is pure speculation, the current black cards being promoted begs the question as to whether M11 or the current block will reprint Dark Ritual (not very likely), Cabal Ritual (more likely than DR), or some new version thereof.
Did I miss anything? Which specific ...
Started 1 week, 3 days ago (2009-10-31 20:30:00)
by KrackShott
All those are are just a reprint for the newer players who might have
missed out on the books the first time around. Someone would bring that up
if that ever happened. It's not even worth being called a coincidence (did
I spell that right?) because it's nowhere near. It just happened.
Started 1 week, 2 days ago (2009-11-01 13:05:00)
by onlainari
It's just a speculation forum and I don't expect more than five replies.
I sent this email to the rules team as conflux came out:
Cave
Basic Land - Cave
As long as Cave has a Domain counter, if you would count the number of basic land types, instead count that number and add 1.
T: Add 1 to your mana pool
The rules allow Cave to be a land type. It is not a basic land type.
420....
Started 5 days ago (2009-11-05 23:19:00)
by HeroTheDragon
Broken with Scapeshift combo? I dunno. Seems like there would need to be a bigger drawback than that.
Started 3 days ago (2009-11-07 23:19:00)
by Barinellos
Duress didn't actually get new art for DvD, but instead got new art for M10 that ended up being put into DvD.
I want to say it was mentioned in one of the arcanas and that is why the Demonic side had one extra alt art rather than divine. (Or at least I think it did, not sure 100%)
|
|