Theory | Forum profile

Quote: Originally Posted by i7V7achii7Ve I agree with what you have said before, but what do you mean by "exemplifies the content", are you talking about the actual (example) playing of a song, rapping, or other aspect, or are you talking about the actual evidence? Can you explain this further for me please, because this is really interesting. Thanks Connor, I think this point is most readily seen through an example....

Quote: I think the answers is "hege good judge" clearly allowing a team win a performance debate will cripple our military They either link by rejecting eurocentric hegemony or they don't solve. Also, from what I remember of the round at CEDAs, the black-centric cards they read link. The move for the margins away from the center is another link. 1) You can make this argument using realism good cards 2) You can make this...

Quote: Originally Posted by shreethebsmaster I suppose it depends on how you classify a performance aff, but the answer to this is probably no. Generally, I tend to see "performance" affs as separate from plan-less kritikal affs in that they use different mediums to communicate a message--not merely breaking norms for the sake of breaking them but having tangible stylistic differences that accompany it (perhaps the aff or...

I would agree wholeheartedly, but when does a performance stop being a performance and start being a "traditional" aff? One of our teams sings the Blues, but then spreads the rest of the 1AC. His performance of the song is authentic and he truly believes in what he sings - but when he gets to his evidence, the pedal hits the floor... Which sort of breaches the question of framework sort of - how much of the affirmative has to...

Quote: Originally Posted by nathan_debate Even talib quali says "rappers shouldn't be leaders" I think the answers is "hege good judge" the west is the best (i wish I knew where that evidence was) possible rights malthus. (although there is some tension between the former and the later) Common = exploitation of women (have you read his lyrics) And I think Delgado has evidence on the opposite side of...

Quote: Originally Posted by jz01 i dont know if you are kidding. but dont do this. yah, if you debate a performance aff, you say framework and biopower good. works every time

This probably goes in Theory unless it has some specific application to Poverty (especially given the 'structure' questions).

Lane Tech does this 1. Play I just wanna be by Common 2. debate becomes a constant repitition and stops conciousness Freire 70 "pedagogy of the oppressed pg 1997 3. that causes domination 4. that leads to nazism 5. genocide=extinction 6. Reject every loss of liberty Petro 74 7. Plan: The USFG should allow Common to alter reality 8. Solvency- some other common song (dont know the name)

while we're here, is there any explicit rule against playing recordings of music in round?

Alright, so I have an extremely big question to know if anyone is willing to take the time to answer in depth and exactly as I ask. Not trying to be rude or anything, but please don't post shit like, "oh, that's so stupid", or "you will never win with this argument." Anybody with a specific expertise on this would be greatly appreciated if you answer. Question 1: How do you structure a performance...