Shia/Sunni Dialogue | Forum profile

here is a link regarding the sunni view of ali ra its a comprehensive speech - i thought i would share with this beautiful speech here in order to correct the misconceptions regarding the shias percieving the sunnis to dislike ali ra http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pWwuxSlHAQ i would like the shia feedback please

salams bro. lets not highjack any more threads, i want a manazara with you on ANYTHING to do with the differences between shias - but starting with maula ali and muawiyyah (piss be upon him). will you accept?

Assalamu Aleikum From time to time we hear that Imam Ja'far Essadiq ( as ) has taught most sunni scholars such as Ashafii , Malik and others I don't know them . Did he teach them Fiqh only ?

َ فَإِذَا فَرَغْتَ فَانصَبْ {7} QUOTE [Shakir 94:7] So when you are free, nominate. [Pickthal 94:7] So when thou art relieved, still toil Through verse 7 the Holy Prophet is asked to establish imamah or wilayah of Ali ibn abi Talib when he completes the duties of conveying the divine guidance to mankind. In verse 67 of Ma-idah Allah reminds the Holy Prophet: "...

salam, I read somewhere that Abd Allah ibn Masud was a famous scholar of Kufa under which many Sahabas have learn before Imam Ali came to Kufa and estabished his own School. 1-I want to know whta's the opinion of Shias Scholars on Abd Allah ibn Masud ? Is he reliable and do we have hadith from him in our Shias books ? 2-Who was his teacher ? Because we know that Imam Ali's teacher was...

I can prove that its Kufr (rejection) simply by qouting the Quran and Hadith of the Prophet (SAAS). Shall we proceed?

Assalamwalaikum, I don't really appreciate how we always dwell into the hadith first without first looking at the Quran, the thing that both parties can agree on. Tell me all ayaths you guys believe that prove Shia Islam. I'm just doing this for research purposes.

Sab`ul Mathaanee mean the Seven Often Repeated Verses. At sunni mosques I never hear the bismillah which only makes it 6 verses.. Are you guys of muawiyah l.a? He did this and all the sahabas asked muawiyah l.a, ana ana bismillah? Just wondering because if you get the first surah of prayer wrong.. thats a pretty big mistake already.. No offence intended to any sunnis.....

Jooi, what do Sunni's think of Tijani's books; for example: "Ask Those Who Know" ? Have any of them actually read it ? What do you say about the arguments brought therein ? Is there any specific one that you have confidently identified as false, and would like to discuss it here ? With Prayers For Your Success, The Persian Shah

Unlike the Shi'a, there was no such concept of sunni school of thought in the lifetime of the Prophet P.b.u.H. In my opinion, this school of thought was infact nurtured by the enemies of Allah (SWT), His Prophet (SAAS), and Ahlul Bayt . It is rooted in envy and born out of enmity towards the Prophet (SAAS) and his Qurba . The word Shi'a is used in the Quran to describe the faithful ...

here is a link regarding the sunni view of ali ra its a comprehensive speech - i thought i would share with this beautiful speech here in order to correct the misconceptions regarding the shias percieving the sunnis to dislike ali ra http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pWwuxSlHAQ i would like the shia feedback please

Why would they do mutah when there was the option for a permanent marriage?

Assalamwalaikum, I just wanted to know what Shias make of this / their interpretation of these verses... QUOTE "It is not fitting for an Apostle That he should have prisoners of war, Until he has thoroughly subdued the land. Ye look on the temporal goods of this world, But God looks to the Hereafter, And God is Exalted, Mighty, and Wise." (8:67) We know that this is about the ...

Unlike the Shi'a, there was no such concept of sunni school of thought in the lifetime of the Prophet P.b.u.H. In my opinion, this school of thought was infact nurtured by the enemies of Allah (SWT), His Prophet (SAAS), and Ahlul Bayt . It is rooted in envy and born out of enmity towards the Prophet (SAAS) and his Qurba . The word Shi'a is used in the Quran to describe the faithful ...

What is the Sunni comment on this hadith? والحديث يصحح ما في تفسير الطبري ج: 13 ص: 108 : " ذكر من قال ذلك حدثنا أحمد بن يحيى الصوفي قال ثنا الحسن بن الحسين الأنصاري قال ثنا معاذ بن مسلم ثنا الهروي عن عطاء بن السائب عن سعيد بن جبير عن ابن عباس قال لما نزلت ( إنما أنت منذر ولكل قوم هاد ) وضع صلى الله عليه وسلم يده على صدره فقال أنا المنذر ولكل قوم هاد وأومأ بيده إلى منكب علي فقال أنت ...

salams bro. lets not highjack any more threads, i want a manazara with you on ANYTHING to do with the differences between shias - but starting with maula ali and muawiyyah (piss be upon him). will you accept?

Assalamwalaikum, I don't really appreciate how we always dwell into the hadith first without first looking at the Quran, the thing that both parties can agree on. Tell me all ayaths you guys believe that prove Shia Islam. I'm just doing this for research purposes.

Just want to know which of the 12 imams practiced muta. This post has been edited by quantum : Yesterday, 12:46 PM

Assalamwalaikum, Please check out these verses. For some of the topics, such as the Oneness of Allah belief, there are way too many verses, so I will work on providing all of those verses later, Inshallah. However, nobody who claims to be a Muslim should have any out-of-the-contrary views on Allah (swt). Praise of Companions (7:157) "Those who follow the messenger, the...

salam, I read somewhere that Abd Allah ibn Masud was a famous scholar of Kufa under which many Sahabas have learn before Imam Ali came to Kufa and estabished his own School. 1-I want to know whta's the opinion of Shias Scholars on Abd Allah ibn Masud ? Is he reliable and do we have hadith from him in our Shias books ? 2-Who was his teacher ? Because we know that Imam Ali's teacher was...